• Welcome to the Green and Gold Rugby forums. As you can see we've upgraded the forums to new software. Your old logon details should work, just click the 'Login' button in the top right.

Brumbies 2016

Status
Not open for further replies.
Brumby Runner

Brumby Runner

David Wilson (68)
Seb V said:
Didn't he start a test? I recall him being held up on one run and being turned over on another. He seemed to lack mongrel and impact to me.

I think his work rate has increased in the super xv season and is superb but if your picking a lock for his workrate then you can't go past Carter.

Cheika also stated he wanted two types of locks, A line-out specialist which Simmons and Mumm cover, and a bruiser which Douglas and Skelton cover. This is why Horwill missed out as he didn't quite fit the role of either and was more inbetween. Same reason maybe for Jones.

Kind of contradicts the preference of Carter over Jones but then again thats only an assumption anyway. Also questions why Horwill was even given a shot to begin with (over Jones).
Click to expand...

From my recollection (memory only - I haven't checked) Luke came on with about 10 minutes to go in his first cap, and that was when he spilt the ball or got turned over on his first two carries.

In addition to his workrate, he is also a good lineout option, so really offers a lot as a potential lock at test level from next year. As I said, I'm not arguing for his selection over anyone else, including Sam, but I do think he is suffering from a bandwagon effect regarding his supposed poor form at test level.
 
Slim 293

Slim 293

Stirling Mortlock (74)
Brumby Runner said:
As I said, I'm not arguing for his selection over anyone else, including Sam, but I do think he is suffering from a bandwagon effect regarding his supposed poor form at test level.
Click to expand...


Yeah, it seemed fairly unanimous among posters here that Luke Jones would be in the squad at least...........

The discussion about his alleged poor test form didn't start to occur until after the squad was announced............
 
qwerty51

qwerty51

Stirling Mortlock (74)
I'm starting to wonder if Luke Jones did something on the EOYT last year that Cheika didn't like.. off the field.
 
Highlander35

Highlander35

Andrew Slack (58)
It's a world cup year. Making "hard" decisions is part of the program. He's not gonna be selected at tighthead lock, Simmons nailed down the starting loosehead lock. He needed to show he was better than either Mumm or Fardy across 4/6 to be selected and Chieka obviously felt he didn't.

If the lack of selection continues intp 2016, especially if he continues to improve, it's probably fair to start questioning.

Anyway Brumbies, how do you have so many Super Quality Locks? Carter, Fardy, Smiler, Enever and Arnold, with Staniforth coming up behind? Obviously Fardy and to a lesser extent Smiler play a lot of 6, but that's a mighty deep engine room.
 
F

Forcefield

Ken Catchpole (46)
I thought he monkeyed up his starting opportunity on the EOYT with that pass to noone almost within our own 22. Against Ireland I think. You wouldn't see that from Mumm or Fardy. They have the big game experience not to stuff up under pressure. They might not be as barnstorming as Jones but they are safer.
 
Slim 293

Slim 293

Stirling Mortlock (74)
Highlander35 said:
Anyway Brumbies, how do you have so many Super Quality Locks? Carter, Fardy, Smiler, Enever and Arnold, with Staniforth coming up behind? Obviously Fardy and to a lesser extent Smiler play a lot of 6, but that's a mighty deep engine room.
Click to expand...



Enever especially was a revelation at the end of the season when Carter was injured..........

I think he might have wound up topping lineout steals for the Brumbies, although might have to double check that?

The Brumbies are certainly in a good position next year to push for the top of the Aussie conference and have been lucky with the post-RWC exodus with only two high profile departures in White and Mogg.............

Nic White, despite what some think, will be a big loss as if you go back and look at the Brumbies' wins this year he was an integral part in those victories............

Mogg, at his best, could've been something special but there's no denying that over the past two seasons his overall form had dropped off............

It looks to be the best roster they've had since 2013, and the development of some of the fringe forwards such as Ala'alatoa, Smiler, Enever etc. and the addition of experienced players like Andrew Smith and Anae will add good depth to the squad.
 
Viking

Viking

Mark Ella (57)
White is a huge loss and whilst Mogg had his good games and his bad games - combined with White it will have a huge tactical shift.

We lose both players with big boots who often got us out of a lot pressure. This was even notable when Mogg was injured and Coleman was playing fullback.

With both White and Mogg gone we won't have the advantage of the big clearance any more.

Other then that, I think everything else is looking very solid.
 
Caputo

Caputo

Billy Sheehan (19)
http://www.canberratimes.com.au/rug...-renovate-players-in-nrc-20150922-gjsb40.html

This maybe just as important to who is signed but improving those on the books. The example that stood out loudly was in the Vikings v Stars match. We saw the newly renovated outside centre in Ah Wong ready to step in when Kudriani is unavailable. Iona was the same a fit at 10/12 and Anae mentioned as starting on his journey to hooker. This reminds me of John Uligia but he became a better hooker with the Waratahs. Whilst at the Stars used Tilse at Lock.
 
Brumby Jack

Brumby Jack

Steve Williams (59)
Staff member
Brumbies 2016 draw

R1 Fri 26 Feb vs Hurricanes - Canberra
R2 Fri 4 Mar vs Waratahs - Canberra
R3 Fri 11 Mar vs Force - Perth
R4 Sun 20 Mar vs Stormers - Cape Town
R5 Sun 27 Mar vs Cheetahs - Bloemfontein
R6 Sun 2 Apr vs Chiefs - Canberra - 7:40pm
R7 Bye
R8 Sat 16 Apr vs Waratahs - Sydney
R9 Sun 24 Apr vs Crusaders - 4pm
R10 Sat 30 Apr vs Highlanders - NZ (TBC)
R11 Fri 6 May vs Bulls - Canberra
R12 Fri 13 May vs Rebels - Melbourne
R13 Bye
R14 SaT 26 May vs Japan - Canberra
R15 Fri 1 Jul vs Reds - Canberra
R16 Fri 8 Jul vs Blues - Auckland
R17 Sat 15 Jul vs Force - Canberra
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top