Force V Hurricanes @ NIB - Rd 15
- Thread starter ChargerWA
- Start date
- Status
ACR
Bob Davidson (42)
Yeah, replayed it a few times. It is a very soft yellow.
Still doesn't look like the way players normally brace themselves to me, BECAUSE, he had heaps of time to plant his feet and turn his whole body to "side body" him. That's not "bracing".
I can feel for the Force fans, Canes should have had some harsher punishment earlier in the game.
Still doesn't look like the way players normally brace themselves to me, BECAUSE, he had heaps of time to plant his feet and turn his whole body to "side body" him. That's not "bracing".
I can feel for the Force fans, Canes should have had some harsher punishment earlier in the game.
Shiggins
Steve Williams (59)
Ummmmmm what. The force have been to south Africa. Then south America. Then over new Zealand and east coast of Australia back to Perth then to Queensland then back to Perth without a break. So who should be fatigued?
Sent from my SM-G928I using Tapatalk
Dismal Pillock
Simon Poidevin (60)
Engrossing fixture. Force seemed gee’d up by their crowd.
The Canes, don’t think I’ve ever seen goalline D like that before, for that length of time. The Force must’ve been on attack inside the Canes 22 for 30 goddamn minutes.
Thought Shiggins went well. Just went out and played his usual game. You know what you’re going to get with Shiggins, week in and week out. No frills. Certainly no silly pictures or GIFS. Except for that one time he posted that picture of the net full of fish he’d “caught” that still had price tags on them.
The Canes, don’t think I’ve ever seen goalline D like that before, for that length of time. The Force must’ve been on attack inside the Canes 22 for 30 goddamn minutes.
Thought Shiggins went well. Just went out and played his usual game. You know what you’re going to get with Shiggins, week in and week out. No frills. Certainly no silly pictures or GIFS. Except for that one time he posted that picture of the net full of fish he’d “caught” that still had price tags on them.
That DHP yellow was a stinker. Perenara tried to run straight through him. DHP was static, held his ground. I'm not sure what else DHP could have done. Looked at end-on, like all players would necessarily see it, there was nothing to penalise, let alone card.
That was a 14 point screw up by the officialdom.
I agree with one of the commentators who said that rugby is one of three contact sports in Australia and the TMO is ruining it.
That was a 14 point screw up by the officialdom.
I agree with one of the commentators who said that rugby is one of three contact sports in Australia and the TMO is ruining it.
M
Moono75
Guest
Tough competitive game. Loss of Coleman and DHP for a dubious yellow card turned the game. Hurricanes are good finishers but they push the boundaries of being offside. TMO killed it and the Canes took advantage.
The Force again show why we belong with another combative committed game. Hardwicks late try taking defenders over the line was all guts!
The Force again show why we belong with another combative committed game. Hardwicks late try taking defenders over the line was all guts!
Nipper
Ward Prentice (10)
As usual, Hoffman stinks up a good game. Also, per usual, Kiwi side infringe regularly and repeatedly inside their 10m: Canes clearly in from the side on a Force maul, to turn it over, offside all day long, pathetic yellow on DHP after some soccer antics by Perenera (that was the TMO), then he awards a meaningless yellow when the game is out of reach, just to say, "see, I called them out on it."
But, jeez - I admire the attitude, but you've got to take the points, especially after the first couple of mauls don't pay.
Still, the Force gave a kiwi side the toughest game of all Aussie opponents. Low bar, I know...
But, jeez - I admire the attitude, but you've got to take the points, especially after the first couple of mauls don't pay.
Still, the Force gave a kiwi side the toughest game of all Aussie opponents. Low bar, I know...
Dan54
Tim Horan (67)
Well on the YC, I personally thought it was harsh, I know he turned his shoulder into TJ, and I know he allowed to hold ground, so maybe a penalty if they really feel he needed to be punished. As for TJ diving, that is just ridiculous, if any of you lot can run into a braced man and keep running you should be playing rugby and not wasting your time posting on forums!! The other thing was if you watch both players I thought they were both watching the ball, so....anyway I thought he was hard done by getting a YC. Mind you the earlier high hit on Riccitelli by I can't remember who could very well of been one as although I would of not have given one it was definitely contact to head. All in all I thought the Force put up a decent scrap, and perhaps just lack enough creativity in attack.
The_Brown_Hornet
John Eales (66)
Once again the boys fought gamely but weren't able to turn that into a win. Myself and many in the crowd were calling for them to take the points when we were camped in the Canes 22. I admire the attitude but it struck me as a little tactically naive. For mine you've got to come away with points as often as possible when you're in the opposition red zone. That's just good percentage footy.
The Canes themselves defended well but jeez they were offside a lot. Their counter attack is just devastating though and that's the key thing that wins them so many games. They have the ability to absorb the pressure and then realign and burn you in attack. I'd also like to see TJ get shitmixed by someone, because he's your classical gobby/diving/showboating halfback. He's far from alone though (I have a pathological hatred of halfbacks and their small man ways -- it's something I'm working through with my psychologist).
The Canes themselves defended well but jeez they were offside a lot. Their counter attack is just devastating though and that's the key thing that wins them so many games. They have the ability to absorb the pressure and then realign and burn you in attack. I'd also like to see TJ get shitmixed by someone, because he's your classical gobby/diving/showboating halfback. He's far from alone though (I have a pathological hatred of halfbacks and their small man ways -- it's something I'm working through with my psychologist).
GaffaCHinO
Peter Sullivan (51)
Explain to me how it was avoidable?
DHP didn't change his line and had he not turned to brace himself he would have been shirt fronted by Perenara and would have risked being knocked out.
The idea that players have/had time to get out of the way is just crazy. The pase that these games are being played is insane.
If DHP didn't turn and Perenara ran straight at him and knocked him out would Perenara be penalised? No nor should he it was a poor call from the TMO even Hoff didn't want to make it but he didn't have the balls to tell the TMO to stay out of it.
Slim 293
Stirling Mortlock (74)
He could've held his ground, or even made a legitimate effort to turn and chase the kick but instead he shifts his body towards Perenara and puts his right shoulder into him.........
I don't see a problem with the card.
B
BLR
Guest
He was ok for much of last night, give him a year or so and he might develop the way Gardner has, I just hope we aren't the training team like we were with Gardner.
Shiggins
Steve Williams (59)
Tj fell Backwards and then threw both his arms Back once he was on the ground and acted dead. Not even hurt. He acted dead. Soccer at its best
Sent from my SM-G928I using Tapatalk
Shiggins
Steve Williams (59)
So is dhp suppose to stand there and risk getting hurt? Or Protect himself?
Sent from my SM-G928I using Tapatalk
- Status