I
I do have to ask about two of your statements, because if true, then there is no hope for rugby and the white flag may as well be raised.
If those who play school and Subbies rugby are not interested in supporting the 3rd tier of rugby (as NRC would be unnecessary) that they are connected to, then what hope is there. Not to mention, the most entertaining rugby in town. The fact that people still purchase Super and Wallaby tickets – despite recent results – suggests otherwise.
And if people won’t play because they don’t make the top grade, how do most SS Clubs field so many teams. In the proposed scenario these players are still playing rugby, still with their mates, still connected to the SS Club – albeit differently – and still in the area. If correct, your theory also suggests those players who don’t quite make it have no ambition to earn a place for higher honours? Again, if true, that’s an attitude problem that may very well explain the difference between Aus and NZ rugby right there.
I have faith that rugby players want to play rugby. While considerations of history and tradition are components, they are not the only drivers. Under the suggested structure, mateship, club ethos and love of the game are all still there. And with the local connections to SS, the history and tradition are changed, not removed.
Respectfully,
RC