T
Train Without a Station
Guest
Pocock's figures are way off. He's apparently grown 7cm since 2010 despite looking shorter than people listed at the same height.
The impending Hooper vs Pocock Dilemma
- Thread starter Hoolly Doolly
- Start date
- Status
Rugbynutter39
Michael Lynagh (62)
Had pocock listed as 117kg on Saturday night which surprised me....
Scrubber2050
Mark Ella (57)
Reportedly Poey off to England to "study" - now I thought that's a bloke who is putting his post rugby future ahead of playing in Australia.
Coincidentally a report now that he may be offered $ 3 million to play in England.
Play rugby Poey, study later. Good onya.
Personally I think Poey is an average No. 8 but the world's best 7.
Michael H must be rubbing his hands with glee - First Gill and now possibly Poey.
Coincidentally a report now that he may be offered $ 3 million to play in England.
Play rugby Poey, study later. Good onya.
Personally I think Poey is an average No. 8 but the world's best 7.
Michael H must be rubbing his hands with glee - First Gill and now possibly Poey.
BDA
Peter Johnson (47)
He's got his hands full with Sean McMahon I'd say. I really expect McMahon to start challenging Hooper for that spot.
The_Brown_Hornet
John Eales (66)
Yeah he's a bloody goer is McMahon. Love his attitude, just loves smashing blokes and doing the dirty yards. With that said, the combo of Hooper and Pocock has worked so incredibly well -- certainly against my predictions. I thought it would be worth a go but never did I think it would provide that X factor that nearly got us all the way last year.
HighPlainsDrifter
Jimmy Flynn (14)
Alzheimer's test now incorporates a new question to assess patients : Do you remember "The impending Hooper VS Pocock Dilemma" thread of 2015 ? "But Doctor ...I didn't know it was still a problem and I can't remember why ?" Doctor : "Alas you failed to mention The Pooper antidote ...I'm afraid you may have an early onset of dementia or you just may be too complacent , I'll just write you a script for a copy of the last Eden Park Test as a form of shock therapy which I suspect may trigger memories of the Wallabies gallant 2015 RWC campaign ....If not we'll wait for a new film in the development stage "Pocock's $3 mill Gap Year" ..... Pocock likely to be played by Kevin Hart or Denzel Washington ( in case the Academy has a change of heart) movie to be financed by Caterpillar Inc and music - Aretha Franklin performing "Chain of Fools (Chain,Chain,Chain for the post 70's crowd)"
BDA
Peter Johnson (47)
Interesting reading back over this thread, knowing what we know now. Not too many outlandish comments. Overall the debate was pretty bang on. In the end, both players in the starting line-up, showed that nearly everyone was right to some extent. (save for those people that said you can't play duel opensides).
Imma miss this debate. It begs the question, what great hair-splitting debates are to come in 2016?
I see a big (worthwhile) debate in our future about using local talent vs overseas based talent for the Rugby Championship.
Imma miss this debate. It begs the question, what great hair-splitting debates are to come in 2016?
I see a big (worthwhile) debate in our future about using local talent vs overseas based talent for the Rugby Championship.
The impending Phipps v Stirzacker dilemma?
The impending Richard Graham sacking dilemma? (after which round will it happen).
The impending Michael Cheika is ruining Australian rugby by not selecting enough young players for the RWC and them all going overseas?
The impending Richard Graham sacking dilemma? (after which round will it happen).
The impending Michael Cheika is ruining Australian rugby by not selecting enough young players for the RWC and them all going overseas?
Highlander35
Andrew Slack (58)
The major concerns on the site re 2 opensides starting, not just the thread generally seemed to be based around either the assumption that they would be played at 6 and 7 rather than 8 and 7, which would have required dropping Fardy, one of the few players who could create the balance, and the assumption that Skelton was potentially in the starting 15 on form, which would have required jumpers at 4, 6 and 8 to compensate, meaning that two opensides was an impossibility from a balance view.
As it turned out, Douglas and Mumm came back, shunting Skelton down the pecking order, and Pococks hands were steady enough at the back of the scrum to let him play 8 instead, so they could play them both without compromising the lineout. Didn't think too many were worried about them being too similar, more about the balance of the team given other incorrect assumptions.
As it turned out, Douglas and Mumm came back, shunting Skelton down the pecking order, and Pococks hands were steady enough at the back of the scrum to let him play 8 instead, so they could play them both without compromising the lineout. Didn't think too many were worried about them being too similar, more about the balance of the team given other incorrect assumptions.
Brumby Runner
Jason Little (69)
And then bringing back the old men from overseas to play the RC. This is the one (issue that is) I like.
Scrubber2050
Mark Ella (57)
Shit if Chek had picked all these young players for RWC we may have come 10th. What, leave that old bloke Pocock out and play Gill or McMahon
Always pick the best players available
wamberal
Phil Kearns (64)
A bit of rotation might be a necessity. But the general point remains. Do not blood players in important matches.
2bluesfan
Nev Cottrell (35)
Is there a tipping pool?
boyo
Mark Ella (57)
Joe Blow
Peter Sullivan (51)
McMahon is much more similar to Hooper as a player and I doubt that they will mesh as well as Hoops and Poey do. There are a couple of other young tearaways coming through as well. What we really need is a big 6/8 who can offset the shorties in the 23.
Even if Pocock does take a year in the UK I am sure he will be available for selection
Even if Pocock does take a year in the UK I am sure he will be available for selection
Scrubber2050
Mark Ella (57)
Agree with a lot of above post.
Pocock a great 7 and OK 8. He will never be a "real" 8 unless he stands in English cowshit for a year and grows a few inches. Think Cheks plan of playing both was good. Poey was the BEST option at 8 but he is a 7.
I too am looking forward to a big line breaking or bending 8 who can also jump with the best of them. If one is found Pocock will take back the Wallaby 7 spot in a heartbeat.
- Status