• Welcome to the forums of Green & Gold Rugby.
    We have recently made some changes to the amount of discussions boards on the forum.
    Over the coming months we will continue to make more changes to make the forum more user friendly for all to use.
    Thanks, Admin.

Wallabies 2021

Dctarget

Tim Horan (67)
LSL (Lukhan Salakaia-Loto)'s not a definite yet. Last night was magnificent but his season so far hasn't been stellar. I want to see his tackling rates go up. Below are ranked locks & backrowers of interest by their tackling percentage for TT + AU. McReight is a freak just quietly. Impressive amount of tackles for someone who's had a few bench starts.
Locks
Hosea = 7/8 + 49/55 = 56/63 = 89%
Swain = 16/19 + 71/83 = 87/102 = 85%
Frost = 61/74 + 20/23 = 81/97 = 84%
Salakaia-Loto = 24/28 + 48/61 = 72/89 = 81%
Neville = 89/111 = 80%

Backrowers
McReight = 124/134 = 93%
Naisarani = 12/13 = 92%
Dempsey = 42/46 = 91%
Wright = 45/50 = 90%
Valetini = 126/141 = 89%
Wilson = 110/127 = 87%
Swinton = 114/131 = 87%
ASY (Angus Scott-Young) = 108/126 = 86%
Harris = 57/73 = 78%
 

hifflepiff

Charlie Fox (21)
Running Hosea and Neville as the starting locks, with LSL (Lukhan Salakaia-Loto) on the bench wouldn't be too bad.

LSL (Lukhan Salakaia-Loto) can cover 4, 5 & 6, whilst Valetini and Wilson (who I assume will be starting) can both cover 6 & 8, which allows you to run a specialist like McReight off the bench.
 

Derpus

Nathan Sharpe (72)
Running Hosea and Neville as the starting locks, with LSL (Lukhan Salakaia-Loto) on the bench wouldn't be too bad.

LSL (Lukhan Salakaia-Loto) can cover 4, 5 & 6, whilst Valetini and Wilson (who I assume will be starting) can both cover 6 & 8, which allows you to run a specialist like McReight off the bench.

I dunno, I still want to see Philip straight back in with LSL (Lukhan Salakaia-Loto). Neville on the bench. But, as with McReight, i reckon Hosea will get some game time this year.
 

Dctarget

Tim Horan (67)
Running Hosea and Neville as the starting locks, with LSL (Lukhan Salakaia-Loto) on the bench wouldn't be too bad.

LSL (Lukhan Salakaia-Loto) can cover 4, 5 & 6, which allows you to run a specialist like McReight on the bench.

I think we'll see Philip as one of the starting locks. Will be back with plenty of time and was immense last year. Calls the lineouts too. Rodda went off injured over night for Lyon buuut probably won't play finals, so might be back in time. Either way, I think one of those two will be starting. Probably Philip.

Richie and Rory Arnold were both injured last weekend, with Richie's injury worse. But neither are coming home so not really relevant.

But yeah I'd go with Neville/Philip with Hosea on the bench. Or Philip/Rodda with Hosea on the bench. I'm curious about Neville because he's been great but will he make it to the RWC and is he worth the investment?
 

Dctarget

Tim Horan (67)
I dunno, I still want to see Philip straight back in with LSL (Lukhan Salakaia-Loto). Neville on the bench. But, as with McReight, i reckon Hosea will get some game time this year.

Yes all these conversations are probably moot as we're doing 3 games in 11 days and will see some combinations and debuts that normally wouldn't happen.
 

KOB1987

John Eales (66)
Doubt we'll be carrying a 7 on our bench.

I think it depends on who the 6 and 8 and reserve lock are, and of course we could go a 6:2 split. The main problem with Hooper/Pocock is that it would have been more ideal to finish with it rather than start with it. Hooper and McReight going nuts for the last 20 certainly has some appeal.
 

Wilson

Phil Kearns (64)
Not sure I'd be rushing Perese into the wallabies yet. He's had a huge impact at Super Rugby level but he's still putting in uneven performances - plenty of pushed passes, passes to no one and defensive miss reads. He's just not delivering that consistency you want to see in test match rugby.

Don't get me wrong, I'd have him in the squad and be considering giving him game time with the short turn arounds against France, but I'd still have Paisami/Perese behind Paisami/Ikitau and probably To'omua/Paisami.
 

Dctarget

Tim Horan (67)
Not sure I'd be rushing Perese into the wallabies yet. He's had a huge impact at Super Rugby level but he's still putting in uneven performances - plenty of pushed passes, passes to no one and defensive miss reads. He's just not delivering that consistency you want to see in test match rugby.

Don't get me wrong, I'd have him in the squad and be considering giving him game time with the short turn arounds against France, but I'd still have Paisami/Perese behind Paisami/Ikitau and probably To'omua/Paisami.

At the moment he's more consistent than Petaia. And he's boshing players in the TT that he'd be playing against in a Bledisloe.
 

TSR

Andrew Slack (58)
LSL (Lukhan Salakaia-Loto)'s not a definite yet. Last night was magnificent but his season so far hasn't been stellar. I want to see his tackling rates go up. Below are ranked locks & backrowers of interest by their tackling percentage for TT + AU. McReight is a freak just quietly. Impressive amount of tackles for someone who's had a few bench starts.
Locks
Hosea = 7/8 + 49/55 = 56/63 = 89%
Swain = 16/19 + 71/83 = 87/102 = 85%
Frost = 61/74 + 20/23 = 81/97 = 84%
Salakaia-Loto = 24/28 + 48/61 = 72/89 = 81%
Neville = 89/111 = 80%

Backrowers
McReight = 124/134 = 93%
Naisarani = 12/13 = 92%
Dempsey = 42/46 = 91%
Wright = 45/50 = 90%
Valetini = 126/141 = 89%
Wilson = 110/127 = 87%
Swinton = 114/131 = 87%
ASY (Angus Scott-Young) = 108/126 = 86%
Harris = 57/73 = 78%
I think you have to compare these stats in combination with their contribution in attack. Some players have high stats on one side of the ball, but low on the other.

On top of that there has to be consideration of other factors which aren’t all measured by stats -
- lineout takes & steals (you’d hope all the locks would be up there)
- scrum proficiency
- breakdown activity & accuracy
- ability to disrupt opposition maul
- post contact metres, passes, offloads

If we are already including guys like Wilson & Valetini in our first choice pack I think the test level experience we have will also be valued on the 50/50 calls.

LSL (Lukhan Salakaia-Loto) took some time to get going this year - but TT form will count for a lot.

Personally he’s my first picked lock because I think he covers all of the above better than all of the alternatives but the plus for me is options are emerging who are competing across all the requirements of a modern lock and there is going to be competition for the spot.

Speaking of competition for the spot, I am happy with Valetini & Wilson as our starting 6 & 8, but Michael Wells really impressed me and, while he wasn’t named in the Wallaby squad earlier this year he must be putting some pressure on the likes of Anstee, Kemeny and Swinton for a squad spot at least.
 

Sully

Tim Horan (67)
Staff member
signal-2021-05-30-183510.jpeg


LSL (Lukhan Salakaia-Loto) the only Aussie Lock on Stan's list. That will do me.
 

TSR

Andrew Slack (58)
There are a couple of surprises there for me.

Campbell at 15 & Ala'alatoa above Tupou. I get he has higher workrate but I would’ve thought Tupou’s involvements had much more influence.

Also surprised neither Smith nor Mounga got a mention.
 

D-Box

Cyril Towers (30)
LSL (Lukhan Salakaia-Loto)'s not a definite yet. Last night was magnificent but his season so far hasn't been stellar. I want to see his tackling rates go up. Below are ranked locks & backrowers of interest by their tackling percentage for TT + AU. McReight is a freak just quietly. Impressive amount of tackles for someone who's had a few bench starts.
Locks
Hosea = 7/8 + 49/55 = 56/63 = 89%
Swain = 16/19 + 71/83 = 87/102 = 85%
Frost = 61/74 + 20/23 = 81/97 = 84%
Salakaia-Loto = 24/28 + 48/61 = 72/89 = 81%
Neville = 89/111 = 80%

Backrowers
McReight = 124/134 = 93%
Naisarani = 12/13 = 92%
Dempsey = 42/46 = 91%
Wright = 45/50 = 90%
Valetini = 126/141 = 89%
Wilson = 110/127 = 87%
Swinton = 114/131 = 87%
ASY (Angus Scott-Young) = 108/126 = 86%
Harris = 57/73 = 78%

I think you forgot to look west of Canberra with this list
 
  • Like
Reactions: TSR

kiap

Steve Williams (59)
Don't know where that comes from, certainly not from watching the matches!
So Simone and Campbell are more influential than Mounga and Barrett? Yeah right!!!
Yeah, I think that came from Cheika's presentation pre-TT when he was trying to gussy up the Aussie teams' chances. So, to that extent, it was largely bullshit.

To be fair, and to counter my anti-Cheika bias (Would I take on blind trust what he says about rugby? - Nup) those lists were prepared by some sports data analysis mob.

They basically tried to measure how much each player's on-field performances were correlated with their team's positive outcomes. IIRC, it was based on the separate Ao and (unevenly weak) AU comps. So, not a huge surprise to see AU guys taking out more than half the spots where there are wider gaps between the better and mediocre players.

Stats and damned stats. They can be useful but only if (a) you have a handle on what they're measuring -- a bit vague for Joe Public in this case; and (b) are careful with making extrapolations.
 

barbarian

Phil Kearns (64)
Staff member
I like LSL (Lukhan Salakaia-Loto), he's a test player. Physical, tough, big motor, hurts blokes. All he has to do is show a little bit of form in the next few weeks and he's in my test XV.

Same goes for other proven performers like Nic White, Harry Wilson, Scott Sio.
 
Top