Tah and feathered
Watty Friend (18)
I have heard that the Melbourne Rebels have signed some shute shield players for next season. I don't know names yet.
Shute Shield 2014
- Thread starter Hugh Jarse
- Start date
- Status
AussieDominance
Trevor Allan (34)
Tuatara - Morrison is with Easts now I can't imagine Dowsett would come back to sit behind Holmes, Lucas and Swanapeol.
Brumbies and WA especially I think will look to keep the Super squad players intact.
Aussie D
Dick Tooth (41)
they're only allowed a certain number of super rugby players in each squad (16?) so some will have to move on. A smart super rugby club may choose to align with an unaligned (no super rugby team) NRC club and split their players to ensure that they stay together. Brumbies and NSW Country would seem a natural fit, though not sure if easts and Randwick involvement would scupper any such arrangement.
Anyway, this is the Magners Shute Shield thread 2014 not the Rays NRC thread so maybe move the discussion on which players should be selected over to there.
Anyway, this is the Magners Shute Shield thread 2014 not the Rays NRC thread so maybe move the discussion on which players should be selected over to there.
the coach
Bob Davidson (42)
Have to agree coach they are still a strong chance of making the playoffs
If you take into account the two losses they will have to Parra
Which are the 3 games you assume they will win.
Norths, Gordon, Easts.
Is this over and above the signing of Steve Cummins (Woodies) that has already been announced?
T
turnovertwopasses
Guest
I have new information. Rebels have backed out of the bidding war. They couldn't match the dollars on offer to play lower grades for the Marlins or Students. My prediction is that Uni 3s and Manly 3s will secure one player each.
Dave Beat
Paul McLean (56)
Your intelligence behind the post????
Manly and Uni obviously have the intelligence to manage a P&L and a balance sheet. In actual fact in case you are unaware a lot of clubs are now putting in good practices with regards to their financial
Bomber Harris
Chris McKivat (8)
As a manager of a 4th grade Manly player fielding offers from Uni I can advise all GAGRS that the Rebels offer of $35,000 base plus $1,000 run on and winning bonus plus rent just can't compete with the wealth of the Marlins .
qwerty51
Stirling Mortlock (74)
West Harbour: 1. Michael Ala’alatoa, 2. Ryan Dalziel, 3. Dave Lolohea, 4. Chris Simons, 5. Harrison Orr, 6. Tom Games (c), 7. Cohen Masson, 8. Matt Coles, 9. David Osofua, 10. Alofa Alofa, 11. Tito Mua, 12. Rory Sidey, 13. Usaia O’Sullivan, 14. Macquire Tatola, 15. Joel Brooks.
This true??
This true??
Dave Beat
Paul McLean (56)
Do your fees come out of the 35k.
I like to watch
David Codey (61)
Who cares?
I think I might PM him,and try and get a start down there!
I think I might PM him,and try and get a start down there!
Shute Shield (First Grade only) Discipline Summary to Round 11 :
Club Discipline Record
Send Off (Red Card)
Manly: 1
West Harbour: 1, (Second YC in the same game)
Sin Bin (Yellow Card)
Penrith: 10
Eastern Suburbs: 8
Gordon: 7
Manly: 6
Randwick: 6
Eastwood: 5
Parramatta: 5
West Harbour: 5
Southern Districts: 4
Northern Suburbs: 3
Sydney University: 3
Warringah: 3
Total: 65
Individual Discipline Record:
65 Yellow cards have been issued to 57 players (out of 474 players).
8 players have received 2 Yellow Cards.
49 players have received 1 Yellow Card.
2 Red Cards have been issued to 2 Players.
0 Players have received 2 Red Cards.
2 Players have received 1 Red Card.
1 Player has received their Red Card because of their second Yellow Card in the game.
Discipline by Round:
12 Yellow Cards and 0 Red Cards were issued in Round 1
3 Yellow Cards and 0 Red Cards were issued in Round 2
5 Yellow Cards and 0 Red Cards were issued in Round 3
9 Yellow Cards and 0 Red Cards were issued in Round 4
7 Yellow Cards and 0 Red Cards were issued in Round 5
5 Yellow Cards and 0 Red Cards were issued in Round 6
7 Yellow Cards and 1 Red Cards were issued in Round 7
3 Yellow Cards and 0 Red Cards were issued in Round 8
8 Yellow Cards and 1 Red Cards were issued in Round 9
4 Yellow Cards and 0 Red Cards were issued in Round 10
2 Yellow Cards and 0 Red Cards were issued in Round 11
Who pushes the Laws?
37 Yellow Cards have been issued to Starting Forwards
Club Discipline Record
Send Off (Red Card)
Manly: 1
West Harbour: 1, (Second YC in the same game)
Sin Bin (Yellow Card)
Penrith: 10
Eastern Suburbs: 8
Gordon: 7
Manly: 6
Randwick: 6
Eastwood: 5
Parramatta: 5
West Harbour: 5
Southern Districts: 4
Northern Suburbs: 3
Sydney University: 3
Warringah: 3
Total: 65
Individual Discipline Record:
65 Yellow cards have been issued to 57 players (out of 474 players).
8 players have received 2 Yellow Cards.
49 players have received 1 Yellow Card.
2 Red Cards have been issued to 2 Players.
0 Players have received 2 Red Cards.
2 Players have received 1 Red Card.
1 Player has received their Red Card because of their second Yellow Card in the game.
Discipline by Round:
12 Yellow Cards and 0 Red Cards were issued in Round 1
3 Yellow Cards and 0 Red Cards were issued in Round 2
5 Yellow Cards and 0 Red Cards were issued in Round 3
9 Yellow Cards and 0 Red Cards were issued in Round 4
7 Yellow Cards and 0 Red Cards were issued in Round 5
5 Yellow Cards and 0 Red Cards were issued in Round 6
7 Yellow Cards and 1 Red Cards were issued in Round 7
3 Yellow Cards and 0 Red Cards were issued in Round 8
8 Yellow Cards and 1 Red Cards were issued in Round 9
4 Yellow Cards and 0 Red Cards were issued in Round 10
2 Yellow Cards and 0 Red Cards were issued in Round 11
Who pushes the Laws?
37 Yellow Cards have been issued to Starting Forwards
16 = Front Row, 5 = Second Row, 16 = Loose Forwards
19 Yellow Cards have been issued to Starting Backs3 = Halfback/Flyhalf, 8 = Centres, 8 = Back Three
9 Yellow Cards have been issued to Bench Players
Who has been hassling the Scoreboard Attendants?
(First Grade only to Round 11)
Top 10 Point Scorers
David HARVEY, West Harbour, 129 points (3T 33C 16PG)
Hamish ANGUS, Warringah, 113 points (1T 27C 18PG)
Rohan SAIFOLOI, Southern Districts, 111 points (24C 20PG 1FG)
Pierre HOLA, Eastwood, 94 points (1T 22C 15PG)
Dane CHISHOLM, Manly, 87 points (5T 22C 6PG)
Robert MATE, Penrith, 86 points (1T 24C 11PG)
Harrison BERGELIN, Manly, 80 points (16T)
Daniel KELLY, Sydney University, 75 points (2T 19C 9PG)
Jack GRANT, Northern Suburbs, 72 points (2T 10C 14PG)
Terry PRESTON, Gordon, 70 points (5T 9C 9PG)
Top 10 Golden Boots
David HARVEY, West Harbour, 114 points (33C 16PG)
Rohan SAIFOLOI, Southern Districts, 111 points (24C 20PG 1FG)
Hamish ANGUS, Warringah, 108 points (27C 18PG)
Pierre HOLA, Eastwood, 89 points (22C 15PG)
Robert MATE, Penrith, 81 points (24C 11PG)
Daniel KELLY, Sydney University, 65 points (19C 9PG)
Dane CHISHOLM, Manly, 62 points (22C 6PG)
Jack GRANT, Northern Suburbs, 62 points (10C 14PG)
Tom WOODS, Parramatta, 54 points (12C 10PG)
Liam WINDON, Randwick, 53 points (7C 13PG)
Meat Pies
505 tries have been scored by 194 players (out of 474 players) [40%].
280 players have not tasted a meat pie.(60%)
83 Players have scored only 1 try.
111 players have scored 2 or more tries.
71 players have scored 3 or more tries.
21 Players are averaging better than 1 try per fortnight.
Top Individual Try Scorers
Harrison BERGELIN, Manly, 16 tries
James DARGAVILLE, Sydney University, 12 tries
Jarome MACKENZIE, Penrith, 11 tries
Nick BATGER, Eastwood, 10 tries
Harry JONES, Warringah, 8 tries
Denny GODINET, Southern Districts, 8 tries
Sireli TAGICAKIBAU, Warringah, 7 tries
William PATERSON, Eastern Suburbs, 7 tries
John GRANT, Eastwood, 7 tries
David FELTSCHEER, Warringah, 7 tries
Joel BROOKS, West Harbour, 7 tries
Alex SAMOA, Parramatta, 7 tries
Club Try Scoring
Manly, 72 Tries
Eastwood, 54 Tries
Sydney University, 53 Tries
Parramatta, 47 Tries
Warringah, 45 Tries
West Harbour, 45 Tries
Penrith, 41 Tries
Southern Districts, 36 Tries
Northern Suburbs, 32 Tries
Randwick, 31 Tries
Eastern Suburbs, 30 Tries
Gordon, 19 Tries
The Ducks Bum Award (for the least number of tries scored by their Opposition)
Manly, 28 Tries
Sydney University, 29 Tries
Randwick, 32 Tries
Eastwood, 37 Tries
Warringah, 37 Tries
Northern Suburbs, 42 Tries
Parramatta, 42 Tries
Southern Districts, 44 Tries
Eastern Suburbs, 45 Tries
West Harbour, 46 Tries
Gordon, 52 Tries
Penrith, 71 Tries
Good Attack or Bad Defence?
505 Tries in 66 games (42.1 average per team) [Average of 7.6 tries per game]
Club Rotation/Depth
Sydney University, 49 Players
Randwick, 47 Players
Gordon, 43 Players
Eastern Suburbs, 42 Players
Manly, 41 Players
Penrith, 41 Players
Parramatta, 39 Players
Eastwood, 38 Players
Southern Districts, 35 Players
Warringah, 34 Players
West Harbour, 34 Players
Northern Suburbs, 33 Player
Benchwarmers
15 Players: 6 times
Randwick (2 - Round 5, Round 7)
Southern Districts (1 - Round 7)
Warringah (3 - Round 3, Round 4, Round 5)
16 Players: 12 times
Eastern Suburbs (2 - Round 7, Round 8)
Eastwood (1 - Round 6)
Gordon (1 - Round 4)
Northern Suburbs (2 - Round 1, Round 9)
Parramatta (3 - Round 3, Round 9, Round 10)
Southern Districts (1 - Round 6)
Warringah (1 - Round 9)
West Harbour (1 - Round 3)
17 Players: 13 times
18 Players: 19 times
19 Players: 18 times
20 Players: 13 times
21 Players: 14 times
22 Players: 13 times
23 Players: 24 times
By Club
Eastern Suburbs Average: 19 Players. Full Bench used: 1 time.
Eastwood Average: 20 Players. Full Bench used: 1 time.
Gordon Average: 21 Players. Full Bench used: 2 times.
Manly Average: 21 Players. Full Bench used: 1 time.
Northern Suburbs Average: 18 Players. Full Bench used: 1 time.
Parramatta Average: 19 Players. Full Bench used: 0 times.
Penrith Average: 19 Players. Full Bench used: 1 time.
Randwick Average: 20 Players. Full Bench used: 5 times.
Southern Districts Average: 18 Players. Full Bench used: 1 time.
Sydney University Average: 23 Players. Full Bench used: 11 times.
Warringah Average: 18 Players. Full Bench used: 0 times.
West Harbour Average: 18 Players. Full Bench used: 0 times.
(First Grade only to Round 11)
Top 10 Point Scorers
David HARVEY, West Harbour, 129 points (3T 33C 16PG)
Hamish ANGUS, Warringah, 113 points (1T 27C 18PG)
Rohan SAIFOLOI, Southern Districts, 111 points (24C 20PG 1FG)
Pierre HOLA, Eastwood, 94 points (1T 22C 15PG)
Dane CHISHOLM, Manly, 87 points (5T 22C 6PG)
Robert MATE, Penrith, 86 points (1T 24C 11PG)
Harrison BERGELIN, Manly, 80 points (16T)
Daniel KELLY, Sydney University, 75 points (2T 19C 9PG)
Jack GRANT, Northern Suburbs, 72 points (2T 10C 14PG)
Terry PRESTON, Gordon, 70 points (5T 9C 9PG)
Top 10 Golden Boots
David HARVEY, West Harbour, 114 points (33C 16PG)
Rohan SAIFOLOI, Southern Districts, 111 points (24C 20PG 1FG)
Hamish ANGUS, Warringah, 108 points (27C 18PG)
Pierre HOLA, Eastwood, 89 points (22C 15PG)
Robert MATE, Penrith, 81 points (24C 11PG)
Daniel KELLY, Sydney University, 65 points (19C 9PG)
Dane CHISHOLM, Manly, 62 points (22C 6PG)
Jack GRANT, Northern Suburbs, 62 points (10C 14PG)
Tom WOODS, Parramatta, 54 points (12C 10PG)
Liam WINDON, Randwick, 53 points (7C 13PG)
Meat Pies
505 tries have been scored by 194 players (out of 474 players) [40%].
280 players have not tasted a meat pie.(60%)
83 Players have scored only 1 try.
111 players have scored 2 or more tries.
71 players have scored 3 or more tries.
21 Players are averaging better than 1 try per fortnight.
Top Individual Try Scorers
Harrison BERGELIN, Manly, 16 tries
James DARGAVILLE, Sydney University, 12 tries
Jarome MACKENZIE, Penrith, 11 tries
Nick BATGER, Eastwood, 10 tries
Harry JONES, Warringah, 8 tries
Denny GODINET, Southern Districts, 8 tries
Sireli TAGICAKIBAU, Warringah, 7 tries
William PATERSON, Eastern Suburbs, 7 tries
John GRANT, Eastwood, 7 tries
David FELTSCHEER, Warringah, 7 tries
Joel BROOKS, West Harbour, 7 tries
Alex SAMOA, Parramatta, 7 tries
Club Try Scoring
Manly, 72 Tries
Eastwood, 54 Tries
Sydney University, 53 Tries
Parramatta, 47 Tries
Warringah, 45 Tries
West Harbour, 45 Tries
Penrith, 41 Tries
Southern Districts, 36 Tries
Northern Suburbs, 32 Tries
Randwick, 31 Tries
Eastern Suburbs, 30 Tries
Gordon, 19 Tries
The Ducks Bum Award (for the least number of tries scored by their Opposition)
Manly, 28 Tries
Sydney University, 29 Tries
Randwick, 32 Tries
Eastwood, 37 Tries
Warringah, 37 Tries
Northern Suburbs, 42 Tries
Parramatta, 42 Tries
Southern Districts, 44 Tries
Eastern Suburbs, 45 Tries
West Harbour, 46 Tries
Gordon, 52 Tries
Penrith, 71 Tries
Good Attack or Bad Defence?
505 Tries in 66 games (42.1 average per team) [Average of 7.6 tries per game]
Club Rotation/Depth
Sydney University, 49 Players
Randwick, 47 Players
Gordon, 43 Players
Eastern Suburbs, 42 Players
Manly, 41 Players
Penrith, 41 Players
Parramatta, 39 Players
Eastwood, 38 Players
Southern Districts, 35 Players
Warringah, 34 Players
West Harbour, 34 Players
Northern Suburbs, 33 Player
Benchwarmers
15 Players: 6 times
Randwick (2 - Round 5, Round 7)
Southern Districts (1 - Round 7)
Warringah (3 - Round 3, Round 4, Round 5)
16 Players: 12 times
Eastern Suburbs (2 - Round 7, Round 8)
Eastwood (1 - Round 6)
Gordon (1 - Round 4)
Northern Suburbs (2 - Round 1, Round 9)
Parramatta (3 - Round 3, Round 9, Round 10)
Southern Districts (1 - Round 6)
Warringah (1 - Round 9)
West Harbour (1 - Round 3)
17 Players: 13 times
18 Players: 19 times
19 Players: 18 times
20 Players: 13 times
21 Players: 14 times
22 Players: 13 times
23 Players: 24 times
By Club
Eastern Suburbs Average: 19 Players. Full Bench used: 1 time.
Eastwood Average: 20 Players. Full Bench used: 1 time.
Gordon Average: 21 Players. Full Bench used: 2 times.
Manly Average: 21 Players. Full Bench used: 1 time.
Northern Suburbs Average: 18 Players. Full Bench used: 1 time.
Parramatta Average: 19 Players. Full Bench used: 0 times.
Penrith Average: 19 Players. Full Bench used: 1 time.
Randwick Average: 20 Players. Full Bench used: 5 times.
Southern Districts Average: 18 Players. Full Bench used: 1 time.
Sydney University Average: 23 Players. Full Bench used: 11 times.
Warringah Average: 18 Players. Full Bench used: 0 times.
West Harbour Average: 18 Players. Full Bench used: 0 times.
Inside Shoulder
Nathan Sharpe (72)
Fast fact: 16 of the 23 players in this weekend's Wallabies squad came through the Shute Shield. It was the same with last week's team. Congratulations to NSW Rugby and the Sydney Rugby Union for continuing to produce outstanding talent. May the National Rugby Championship strengthen the production line further.
Read more: http://www.smh.com.au/rugby-union/union-news/israel-folau-in-demand-but-staying-in-super-rugby-with-nsw-waratahs-20140612-zs5ke.html#ixzz34QAbZ8T1
ARU: When you're dreaming up new comps and how to structure and pay for them just remember this.
First, do no harm!
Read more: http://www.smh.com.au/rugby-union/union-news/israel-folau-in-demand-but-staying-in-super-rugby-with-nsw-waratahs-20140612-zs5ke.html#ixzz34QAbZ8T1
ARU: When you're dreaming up new comps and how to structure and pay for them just remember this.
First, do no harm!
Bomber Harris
Chris McKivat (8)
DB absolutely not I add VAT just like east end gezers
Dave Beat
Paul McLean (56)
Awesome stat, and why the best should be returning to their clubs if not playing super. The players should be exposed to quality rugby if we are to compete at the highest levels.
Super players playing rugby in inferior comps is wrong.
Bomber Harris
Chris McKivat (8)
Love HJ's stats . Manly v Uni GF but I always rate defence and so does Warren Ryan . "Quitten' time! "
PC gone mad.
I don't have much time for mungoland but that is ridiculous. It is (or at the time was) OK for the Chaser team to portray a fellow media person on TV as a dogfokker, yet Wokker is in deep do do for quoting licherachewer to mungolanders.
Inside Shoulder
Nathan Sharpe (72)
Well, as a mate of mine living in the US said when reading the story on my Facebook page: its all very well to justify saying it by reference to a 1939 movie but the game he was calling wasn't taking place in 1939.
And I thought to myself.....hmmm....maybe that's it.
I must say HJ I do not consider myself PC but what he said is indefensible:
^^ The actual sound tape is different to what was reported in the paper. The quote was OK but not his preamble.
- Status