• Welcome to the Green and Gold Rugby forums. As you can see we've upgraded the forums to new software. Your old logon details should work, just click the 'Login' button in the top right.

Shute Shield 2014

Status
Not open for further replies.
T

turnovertwopasses

Guest
I'll be there for what should be a cracking day of footy at Rat Park. Tipping Manly by 15+ in both 1sts and 2nds.
 

Iluvmyfooty

Phil Hardcastle (33)
Just 3 rods to go befor semis. I think teh final six in each grade will remain the same until then. Uni will overtake Warringah in1st grade for 3rd position but I think all other grades will remain the same order.
 

Dave Beat

Paul McLean (56)
Go shopping at;
- http://www.store.paladinsports.com.au/manly-marlins-rugby

Marlins.jpg
 

Knuckles

Ted Thorn (20)
Lots of rumours but shortage of facts.
I thought he was the "buy" of the year after the early rounds.
Not sure why he was dropped to 2nds, but his form certainly fell away once he was in seconds IMO.
He's clearly too good a player to be playing subbies but the rumour is that he'll be back at Wests next year OR maybe he'll come back to the Wicks depending on who the coach is next year.;)

He won't be in Australia next year................well not until at-least June anyway. My mail is he wasn't happy at Randwick with all the traveling and not getting paid and has signed a deal to go to one of the bigger clubs in Spain (I believe same club as Vaughan Lomax) end of July so he wanted to play his last few rounds where it all started for him at St Pats. He was a student at the school and will play 3 to 4 games and then head to Europe.
 

Spewn

Alex Ross (28)
Dave, the boys gave us plenty to cheer about again on the weekend.. Firstly, our 2s played loosely but scored after the bell (16 phases) to bring up a bonus point win 26-25. By all accounts 1s trained bloody hard during the week - knowing that Easts had knocked off Manly the week before. Easts had a slim lead at halftime but the passes began to stick in the 2nd half just they like did against Norths. Some awesome tries and great performances from Jonno Broome, Jack Dempsey, Tom Matthews, Lucas Simkin and Matt McDougall gave us a 46-22 win. 5 wins for the year (one less that 6th-placed Parra) but a shocking lack of bonus points has us in 11th. 3 rounds to go. bring on 3 wins...;)
Great win to Gordon. Their back line was as slick as I have seen this year. Easts were clumsy in comparison. I can only assume injuries have plagued Gordon's season. Easts on the other hand don't seem to be able to pick a decent team even allowing for injuries. They occasionally win when one or two super 15 players return, but otherwise suck. What I don't get is the selection of the same players every week despite weak performances. Do the coaches know what they're doing? Did Bakewell leave because he could see the writing on the wall? Why is there the same 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, and 7 every week? Or the same 9?
 

the coach

Bob Davidson (42)
Great win to Gordon. Their back line was as slick as I have seen this year. Easts were clumsy in comparison. I can only assume injuries have plagued Gordon's season. Easts on the other hand don't seem to be able to pick a decent team even allowing for injuries. They occasionally win when one or two super 15 players return, but otherwise suck. What I don't get is the selection of the same players every week despite weak performances. Do the coaches know what they're doing? Did Bakewell leave because he could see the writing on the wall? Why is there the same 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, and 7 every week? Or the same 9?

Or are Easts problems partially due to their coach's departure after a few rounds?
Is my memory failing me or is this not the second time Bakewell has left mid-season?
 

AussieDominance

Trevor Allan (34)
For Gordon Matthews has been outstanding the last few rounds if he keeps going he would have to be on rep selectors radar's.

Simkin has done well since coming back and Dempsey has displayed why he is so highly rated.

Will be interesting to see what they do with Broome returning next season as Dempsey would be a 7 in professional set up I believe and Broome is very short and only really a 7.
 

Hugh Jarse

Rocky Elsom (76)
Staff member
Shute Shield (First Grade only) Discipline Summary to Round 14 :
(belated post - Round 15 Stats coming soon)

Club Discipline Record
Send Off (Red Card)
Manly: 1
West Harbour: 1, (Second YC in the same game)

Sin Bin (Yellow Card)
Penrith: 13
Eastern Suburbs: 10
Manly: 10
Gordon: 8
Parramatta: 8
Eastwood: 7
Randwick: 6
Southern Districts: 5
West Harbour: 5
Northern Suburbs: 4
Sydney University: 4
Warringah: 4
Total: 84


Individual Discipline Record:
84 Yellow cards have been issued to 73 players (out of 515 players).
11 players have received 2 Yellow Cards.
62 players have received 1 Yellow Card.

2 Red Cards have been issued to 2 Players.
0 Players have received 2 Red Cards.
2 Players have received 1 Red Card.
1 Player has received their Red Card because of their second Yellow Card in the game.


Discipline by Round:
12 Yellow Cards and 0 Red Cards were issued in Round 1
3 Yellow Cards and 0 Red Cards were issued in Round 2
5 Yellow Cards and 0 Red Cards were issued in Round 3
9 Yellow Cards and 0 Red Cards were issued in Round 4
7 Yellow Cards and 0 Red Cards were issued in Round 5
5 Yellow Cards and 0 Red Cards were issued in Round 6
7 Yellow Cards and 1 Red Cards were issued in Round 7
3 Yellow Cards and 0 Red Cards were issued in Round 8
8 Yellow Cards and 1 Red Cards were issued in Round 9
4 Yellow Cards and 0 Red Cards were issued in Round 10
2 Yellow Cards and 0 Red Cards were issued in Round 11
8 Yellow Cards and 0 Red Cards were issued in Round 12
9 Yellow Cards and 0 Red Cards were issued in Round 13
2 Yellow Cards and 0 Red Cards were issued in Round 14

Who pushes the Laws?
48 Yellow Cards have been issued to Starting Forwards
18 = Front Row, 9 = Second Row, 21 = Loose Forwards​
26 Yellow Cards have been issued to Starting Backs
7 = Halfback/Flyhalf, 10 = Centres, 9 = Back Three​
10 Yellow Cards have been issued to Bench Players
 

Hugh Jarse

Rocky Elsom (76)
Staff member
Who has been hassling the Scoreboard Attendants?
(First Grade only to Round 14) (belated post - Round 15 stats summary coming soon)

Top 10 Point Scorers
Hamish ANGUS, Warringah, (13), 156 points (3T 36C 23PG)
David HARVEY, West Harbour, (11), 129 points (3T 33C 16PG)
Rohan SAIFOLOI, Southern Districts, (13), 127 points (29C 22PG 1FG)
Dane CHISHOLM, Manly, (8), 121 points (7T 28C 10PG)
Robert MATE, Penrith, (14), 99 points (1T 29C 12PG)
Pierre HOLA, Eastwood, (8), 94 points (1T 22C 15PG)
Terry PRESTON, Gordon, (14), 89 points (5T 17C 10PG)
Daniel KELLY, Sydney University, (7), 87 points (2T 25C 9PG)
Harrison BERGELIN, Manly, (14), 80 points (16T)
James DARGAVILLE, Sydney University, (14), 80 points (16T)

Note: Number in brackets is the number of run on starts the player has had.

Top 10 Golden Boots
Hamish ANGUS, Warringah, (13), 141 points (36C 23PG)
Rohan SAIFOLOI, Southern Districts, (13), 127 points (29C 22PG 1FG)
David HARVEY, West Harbour, (11), 114 points (33C 16PG)
Robert MATE, Penrith, (14), 94 points (29C 12PG)
Pierre HOLA, Eastwood, (8), 89 points (22C 15PG)
Dane CHISHOLM, Manly, (8), 86 points (28C 10PG)
Daniel KELLY, Sydney University, (7), 77 points (25C 9PG)
Jack GRANT, Northern Suburbs, (10), 66 points (12C 14PG)
Terry PRESTON, Gordon, (14), 64 points (17C 10PG)
Tom WOODS, Parramatta, (7), 63 points (15C 11PG)

Meat Pies
640 tries have been scored by 217 players (out of 515 players) [42%].
298 players have not tasted a meat pie [58%].
85 players have scored only 1 try.
132 players have scored 2 or more tries.
92 players have scored 3 or more tries.
60 players have scored 4 or more tries.
14 players are averaging better than 1 try per fortnight.


Top Individual Try Scorers
Harrison BERGELIN, Manly, 16 tries, (14 starts)
James DARGAVILLE, Sydney University, 16 tries, (14 starts)
John GRANT, Eastwood, 13 tries, (9 starts)
Jarome MACKENZIE, Penrith, 12 tries, (13 starts)
Nick BATGER, Eastwood, 12 tries, (14 starts)
Henry CLUNIES-ROSS, Sydney University, 10 tries, (8 starts)
Joel BROOKS, West Harbour, 9 tries, (13 starts)
Harry JONES, Warringah, 8 tries, (5 starts)
Michael SNOWDEN, Eastwood, 8 tries, (10 starts)
Larry HERMENS, Parramatta, 8 tries, (10 starts)
Tito MUA, West Harbour, 8 tries, (11 starts)
Lupini SIALE, Manly, 8 tries, (13 starts)
Denny GODINET, Southern Districts, 8 tries, (14 starts)
David FELTSCHEER, Warringah, 8 tries, (14 starts)
Sireli TAGICAKIBAU, Warringah, 8 tries, (14 starts)

Club Try Scoring
Manly, 83 Tries
Eastwood, 73 Tries
Sydney University, 72 Tries
Warringah, 57 Tries
Parramatta, 54 Tries
West Harbour, 54 Tries
Penrith, 53 Tries
Southern Districts, 46 Tries
Randwick, 41 Tries
Northern Suburbs, 40 Tries
Eastern Suburbs, 36 Tries
Gordon, 31 Tries

The Ducks Bum Award (for the least number of tries scored by their Opposition)
Manly, 32 Tries
Sydney University, 38 Tries
Randwick, 42 Tries
Eastwood, 44 Tries
Warringah, 46 Tries
Eastern Suburbs, 52 Tries
Parramatta, 55 Tries
Southern Districts, 55 Tries
West Harbour, 61 Tries
Northern Suburbs, 62 Tries
Gordon, 64 Tries
Penrith, 89 Tries


Good Attack or Bad Defence?
640 Tries in 84 games (53 average per team) [Average of 7.6 tries per game]


Club Rotation/Depth
Sydney University, 52 Players
Randwick, 48 Players
Eastern Suburbs, 46 Players
Gordon, 44 Players
Penrith, 44 Players
Manly, 42 Players
Parramatta, 41 Players
Eastwood, 40 Players
Southern Districts, 40 Players
West Harbour, 36 Players
Warringah, 35 Players
Northern Suburbs, 34 Players

Benchwarmers
15 Players: 6 times
Randwick (2 - Round 5, Round 7)
Southern Districts (1 - Round 7)
Warringah (3 - Round 3, Round 4, Round 5)

16 Players: 16 times
Eastern Suburbs (2 - Round 7, Round 8)
Eastwood (2 - Round 6. Round 14)
Gordon (1 - Round 4)
Northern Suburbs (2 - Round 1, Round 9)
Parramatta (4 - Round 3, Round 9, Round 10. Round 14)
Randwick (1 - Round 14)
Southern Districts (1 - Round 6)
Warringah (1 - Round 9)
West Harbour (2 - Round 3. Round 13)

17 Players: 19 times
18 Players: 22 times
19 Players: 21 times
20 Players: 27 times
21 Players: 14 times
22 Players: 14 times
23 Players: 29 times

By Club
Eastern Suburbs Average: 19 Players. Full Bench used: 1 time.
Eastwood Average: 20 Players. Full Bench used: 2 times.
Gordon Average: 21 Players. Full Bench used: 2 times.
Manly Average: 21 Players. Full Bench used: 1 time.
Northern Suburbs Average: 18 Players. Full Bench used: 1 time.
Parramatta Average: 18 Players. Full Bench used: 0 times.
Penrith Average: 19 Players. Full Bench used: 1 time.
Randwick Average: 20 Players. Full Bench used: 5 times.
Southern Districts Average: 19 Players. Full Bench used: 2 times.
Sydney University Average: 23 Players. Full Bench used: 14 times.
Warringah Average: 18 Players. Full Bench used: 0 times.
West Harbour Average: 18 Players. Full Bench used: 0 times.
 

Spewn

Alex Ross (28)
For Gordon Matthews has been outstanding the last few rounds if he keeps going he would have to be on rep selectors radar's.

Simkin has done well since coming back and Dempsey has displayed why he is so highly rated.

Will be interesting to see what they do with Broome returning next season as Dempsey would be a 7 in professional set up I believe and Broome is very short and only really a 7.

From what I've seen, Dempsey is too tall for a 7. Broome is much better but is a tad short. I would have Dempsey at 6 and Broome at 7, and Luke Rissman if he returned at 8.
 

Spewn

Alex Ross (28)
Or are Easts problems partially due to their coach's departure after a few rounds?
Is my memory failing me or is this not the second time Bakewell has left mid-season?

Maybe, but picking the same guys week in week out when the results are poor is hardly inspirational coaching even with a possible lack of depth. If it is not working, why keep repeating the same thing.
 

Spewn

Alex Ross (28)
I'm trying to work out whether Hugh Jarse's stats support what I've just said about Easts. My impression is that the forward pack has not changed much, but there have been changes in the backs.
 

Hugh Jarse

Rocky Elsom (76)
Staff member
@Spewn, Just done the Round 15 Stats. I'll have a lash at checking out the player turn over in the Beastie piggies later in the week.
 

Hugh Jarse

Rocky Elsom (76)
Staff member
Shute Shield (First Grade only) Discipline Summary to Round 15 :


Club Discipline Record
Send Off (Red Card)
Manly: 1
West Harbour: 1, (Second YC in the same game)

Sin Bin (Yellow Card)
Penrith: 13
Manly: 11
Eastern Suburbs: 10
Gordon: 8
Parramatta: 8
Eastwood: 8
Randwick: 8
Southern Districts: 5
West Harbour: 5
Northern Suburbs: 4
Sydney University: 4
Warringah: 4
Total: 88


Individual Discipline Record:
88 Yellow cards have been issued to 75 players (out of 531 players).
13 players have received 2 Yellow Cards.
62 players have received 1 Yellow Card.

2 Red Cards have been issued to 2 Players.
0 Players have received 2 Red Cards.
2 Players have received 1 Red Card.
1 Player has received their Red Card because of their second Yellow Card in the game.


Discipline by Round:
12 Yellow Cards and 0 Red Cards were issued in Round 1
3 Yellow Cards and 0 Red Cards were issued in Round 2
5 Yellow Cards and 0 Red Cards were issued in Round 3
9 Yellow Cards and 0 Red Cards were issued in Round 4
7 Yellow Cards and 0 Red Cards were issued in Round 5
5 Yellow Cards and 0 Red Cards were issued in Round 6
7 Yellow Cards and 1 Red Cards were issued in Round 7
3 Yellow Cards and 0 Red Cards were issued in Round 8
8 Yellow Cards and 1 Red Cards were issued in Round 9
4 Yellow Cards and 0 Red Cards were issued in Round 10
2 Yellow Cards and 0 Red Cards were issued in Round 11
8 Yellow Cards and 0 Red Cards were issued in Round 12
9 Yellow Cards and 0 Red Cards were issued in Round 13
2 Yellow Cards and 0 Red Cards were issued in Round 14
4 Yellow Cards and 0 Red Cards were issued in Round 15

Who pushes the Laws?
51 Yellow Cards have been issued to Starting Forwards
19 = Front Row, 9 = Second Row, 23 = Loose Forwards​
27 Yellow Cards have been issued to Starting Backs
7 = Halfback/Flyhalf, 10 = Centres, 10 = Back Three​
10 Yellow Cards have been issued to Bench Players
 

Hugh Jarse

Rocky Elsom (76)
Staff member
Who has been hassling the Scoreboard Attendants?
(First Grade only to Round 15)

Top 10 Point Scorers
Hamish ANGUS, Warringah, (14), 159 points (3T 36C 24PG)
Dane CHISHOLM, Manly, (9), 134 points (8T 32C 10PG)
David HARVEY, West Harbour, (11), 129 points (3T 33C 16PG)
Rohan SAIFOLOI, Southern Districts, (13), 127 points (29C 22PG 1FG)
Robert MATE, Penrith, (15), 103 points (1T 31C 12PG)
Ben BATGER, Eastwood, (14), 94 points (6T 23C 6PG)
Daniel KELLY, Sydney University, (8), 94 points (2T 27C 10PG)
Pierre HOLA, Eastwood, (8), 94 points (1T 22C 15PG)
Terry PRESTON, Gordon, (15), 89 points (5T 17C 10PG)
James DARGAVILLE, Sydney University, (15), 85 points (17T)

Note: Number in brackets is the number of run on starts the player has had.

Top 10 Golden Boots
Hamish ANGUS, Warringah, (14), 144 points (36C 24PG)
Rohan SAIFOLOI, Southern Districts, (13), 127 points (29C 22PG 1FG)
David HARVEY, West Harbour, (11), 114 points (33C 16PG)
Robert MATE, Penrith, (15), 98 points (31C 12PG)
Dane CHISHOLM, Manly, (9), 94 points (32C 10PG)
Pierre HOLA, Eastwood, (8), 89 points (22C 15PG)
Daniel KELLY, Sydney University, (8), 84 points (27C 10PG)
Tom WOODS, Parramatta, (8), 74 points (19C 12PG)
Jack GRANT, Northern Suburbs, (10), 66 points (12C 14PG)
Ben BATGER, Eastwood, (14), 64 points (23C 6PG)
Terry PRESTON, Gordon, (15), 64 points (17C 10PG)

Meat Pies
694 tries have been scored by 224 players (out of 531 players) [42%].
307 players have not tasted a meat pie [58%].
84 players have scored only 1 try.
140 players have scored 2 or more tries.
96 players have scored 3 or more tries.
64 players have scored 4 or more tries.
12 players are averaging better than 1 try per fortnight.


Top Individual Try Scorers
James DARGAVILLE, Sydney University, 17 tries, (15 starts)
Harrison BERGELIN, Manly, 16 tries, (15 starts)
Nick BATGER, Eastwood, 14 tries, (15 starts)
John GRANT, Eastwood, 13 tries, (10 starts)
Jarome MACKENZIE, Penrith, 12 tries, (13 starts)
Joel BROOKS, West Harbour, 11 tries, (14 starts)
Alexander NORTHAM, Manly, 10 tries, (6 starts)
Henry CLUNIES-ROSS, Sydney University, 10 tries, (9 starts)
Larry HERMENS, Parramatta, 10 tries, (11 starts)
Sireli TAGICAKIBAU, Warringah, 10 tries, (15 starts)
Tito MUA, West Harbour, 9 tries, (12 starts)
David FELTSCHEER, Warringah, 9 tries, (15 starts)

Club Try Scoring
Manly, 90 Tries
Eastwood, 78 Tries
Sydney University, 75 Tries
Parramatta, 60 Tries
Warringah, 60 Tries
West Harbour, 60 Tries
Penrith, 55 Tries
Southern Districts, 53 Tries
Northern Suburbs, 46 Tries
Randwick, 41 Tries
Eastern Suburbs, 39 Tries
Gordon, 37 Tries

The Ducks Bum Award (for the least number of tries scored by their Opposition)
Manly, 32 Tries
Sydney University, 43 Tries
Eastwood, 47 Tries
Randwick, 49 Tries
Warringah, 53 Tries
Eastern Suburbs, 58 Tries
Southern Districts, 58 Tries
Parramatta, 61 Tries
Northern Suburbs, 64 Tries
Gordon, 67 Tries
West Harbour, 67 Tries
Penrith, 95 Tries

Good Attack or Bad Defence?
694 Tries in 90 games (58 average per team) [Average of 7.7 tries per game]


Club Rotation/Depth
Sydney University, 54 Players
Randwick, 53 Players
Penrith, 49 Players
Eastern Suburbs, 47 Players
Manly, 45 Players
Gordon, 44 Players
Parramatta, 44 Players
Southern Districts, 43 Players
Eastwood, 40 Players
Northern Suburbs, 38 Players
Warringah, 37 Players
West Harbour, 37 Players

Benchwarmers
15 Players: 7 times
Randwick (2 - Round 5, Round 7)
Southern Districts (1 - Round 7)
Warringah (4 - Round 3, Round 4, Round 5, Round 15)

16 Players: 18 times
Eastern Suburbs (2 - Round 7, Round 8)
Eastwood (2 - Round 6. Round 14)
Gordon (1 - Round 4)
Northern Suburbs (3 - Round 1, Round 9, Round 15)
Parramatta (4 - Round 3, Round 9, Round 10. Round 14)
Penrith (1 - Round 15)
Randwick (1 - Round 14)
Southern Districts (1 - Round 6)
Warringah (1 - Round 9)
West Harbour (2 - Round 3. Round 13)

17 Players: 19 times
18 Players: 25 times
19 Players: 23 times
20 Players: 28 times
21 Players: 14 times
22 Players: 16 times
23 Players: 30 times

By Club
Eastern Suburbs Average: 19 Players. Full Bench used: 1 time.
Eastwood Average: 20 Players. Full Bench used: 2 times.
Gordon Average: 21 Players. Full Bench used: 2 times.
Manly Average: 21 Players. Full Bench used: 2 times.
Northern Suburbs Average: 18 Players. Full Bench used: 1 time.
Parramatta Average: 18 Players. Full Bench used: 0 times.
Penrith Average: 19 Players. Full Bench used: 1 time.
Randwick Average: 20 Players. Full Bench used: 5 times.
Southern Districts Average: 19 Players. Full Bench used: 2 times.
Sydney University Average: 23 Players. Full Bench used: 14 times.
Warringah Average: 18 Players. Full Bench used: 0 times.
West Harbour Average: 18 Players. Full Bench used: 0 times.
 

Spewn

Alex Ross (28)
@Spewn, Just done the Round 15 Stats. I'll have a lash at checking out the player turn over in the Beastie piggies later in the week.

Thanks, HughJ, I find these stats make interesting reading. It would be useful to see if there is any correlation with performance and position on table. I would have thought that the bench would have been used more by teams struggling (trying to get some impact), but conversely the top teams might empty the bench if they were way on top.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top