Reds 2017
- Thread starter Scrubber2050
- Start date
- Status
Ignoto
John Thornett (49)
To be fair, I'm not terribly fussed at this. If we got Genia back next year and his knees held up, it'd only be a band-aid fix for our problems. Tuttle's performances this year suggest the problem isn't really with our 9 and the cash Genia would demand, would cause other gaping holes not to be plugged.
dru
Tim Horan (67)
Yes I'm happy for Genia to go to another franchise.
Scrubber2050
Mark Ella (57)
Gotta go with what we've got. Tuttle seems to be coming on fine. Frisby a great let down this year - thought 2017 would be great for him but not so.
I just wouldn't look at Genia. Crook knees and lots of other negatives compared with on;y a few short term positives.
Rarely does a great player (in the past) come back and replicate that form towards the end of his career.
I just wouldn't look at Genia. Crook knees and lots of other negatives compared with on;y a few short term positives.
Rarely does a great player (in the past) come back and replicate that form towards the end of his career.
liquor box
Greg Davis (50)
I think if there was a poll of supporters for who we would get back that we have lost/let go the Genia would not be number one choice.
I am pretty sure the number one choice wore a 7 on his back
I am pretty sure the number one choice wore a 7 on his back
Scrubber2050
Mark Ella (57)
Supporters perceptions would be interesting.
A year or so the vast majority would have voted for Quade handsdown.
His form (maybe except the last game) hasn't warranted that belief (well, as yet anyway)
But agree with Liam
A year or so the vast majority would have voted for Quade handsdown.
His form (maybe except the last game) hasn't warranted that belief (well, as yet anyway)
But agree with Liam
No4918
John Hipwell (52)
Well, let's look at it this way. The Reds have looked a lot better with Quade at 10. McIntyre is just not up to it. So was it worth bringing QC (Quade Cooper) back? Yes. Not many expected it to be like old times but no doubt in my mind we needed a quality 10. Who else was there?
Genia - If Tuttle hadn't emerged I'd be all for him back at the Reds but that is a lot less sure than it was. Would be great to get him back in Aus but any franchise will do.
Gill - ABSOLUTE NO BRAINER. BRING THE MAN HOME.
Scrubber2050
Mark Ella (57)
^^^^^
So do you jettison Smith ?
So do you jettison Smith ?
Brumby Runner
David Wilson (68)
Close run with another who had 3 on his back?
Scrubber2050
Mark Ella (57)
Biggest problem for the Reds signing Gilly is that they will have to pay his total contract.
Cannot see the ARU chippimg in because of Hooper, Pocock and the emergence of Alcock.
Don't know if the Reds could afford him on their own
Cannot see the ARU chippimg in because of Hooper, Pocock and the emergence of Alcock.
Don't know if the Reds could afford him on their own
Ignoto
John Thornett (49)
While Gill is a game winner in himself, I thought Gunn showed enough last year to showcase he's got the talent and we should see what he's capable of.
To be honest, I wouldn't be wanting to spend the extra cash on a superstar (i.e. Gill and Genia) rather I'd be using it for attracting a higher skilled coach to support Stiles. We'd probably see a better return on a new Defensive and Skills coach being brought in that we would Gill. Hell, if G Smith is wanting to retire in Australia, we'd be idiots not to hire him as a breakdown and forward skill coach or consultant.
I guess, if the QRU have money to splurge, I'd rather they invest it into the organisation rather than individual brilliance. Unfortunately, it'll take one injury and we'd be in a worse position than we are this year.
To be honest, I wouldn't be wanting to spend the extra cash on a superstar (i.e. Gill and Genia) rather I'd be using it for attracting a higher skilled coach to support Stiles. We'd probably see a better return on a new Defensive and Skills coach being brought in that we would Gill. Hell, if G Smith is wanting to retire in Australia, we'd be idiots not to hire him as a breakdown and forward skill coach or consultant.
I guess, if the QRU have money to splurge, I'd rather they invest it into the organisation rather than individual brilliance. Unfortunately, it'll take one injury and we'd be in a worse position than we are this year.
liquor box
Greg Davis (50)
yes, you should always try to have the best possible player in each position. Smith would be good on bench
liquor box
Greg Davis (50)
the interesting thing recruitment wise is how the players from a franchise that is kicked out get spread out. We need to have a cheque book ready as soon as a decision is made.
Highlander35
Andrew Slack (58)
Obviously the ARU have literally NFI what they were doing but the suggestion seemed to be that Contracted Wallabies (McCalman, Timani, DHP etc.) would be more or less given the choice of where they'd go, contracted Super Players would get asked to go to specific franchises, and uncontacted players all round would be encouraged to go to specific sides but the ARU would have literally no control over that, even in the best of circumstances from their perspective.
Sent from my SM-G935F using Tapatalk
Scrubber2050
Mark Ella (57)
The bloke we need is Jonno Lance.
I would actually place him behind Foley but in front of Quade in resect of Wallaby selection (although for some reason I don't believe that will happen).
IMO he would be a better starting 10 at the Reds.
Having said that I am a firm believer that Lance will be lost to Australian rugby, if and when the Force are expunged. That is a great shame.
I would actually place him behind Foley but in front of Quade in resect of Wallaby selection (although for some reason I don't believe that will happen).
IMO he would be a better starting 10 at the Reds.
Having said that I am a firm believer that Lance will be lost to Australian rugby, if and when the Force are expunged. That is a great shame.
The torpedo
Peter Fenwicke (45)
What you're not considering Scrubber is that Quade can improve his play for the rest of this year and next year.
He would be a good replacement for Hunt if he (Karmichael) leaves though........
upthereds#!
Ken Catchpole (46)
If the force went, both brumbies and rebels would jump on lance. Both have 10s that are ITM cup castoffs.
Scrubber2050
Mark Ella (57)
Torp
Sure Quade can improve his play. On his day QC (Quade Cooper) is the best 10 running around. His days seemed numbered.
I'm just sick and tired waiting for it
Based on form this year Lance is a fair way ahead of Quade.
Sure Quade can improve his play. On his day QC (Quade Cooper) is the best 10 running around. His days seemed numbered.
I'm just sick and tired waiting for it
Based on form this year Lance is a fair way ahead of Quade.
- Status