Round 5 - Brumbies v Reds GIO 18/3

[Wilson]

Silly mistake

 

[dru]

Petaia has a long was to go at 15.

 

[dru]

Why do you have to give a warning? Everyone knows repeated infringements in your own 22 is a yellow.

Edit: except the Kiwis, to which the rule does not apply.

I far as I can see he didn't call the card for cynical play. He called it for repeated. And that should have had a warning.

 

[dru]

Sensational rugby the last couple of minutes

 

[Derpus]

I far as I can see he didn't call the card for cynical play. He called it for repeated. And that should have had a warning.

Is that an actual rule though? Otherwise, nah. They know they can't keep infringing.

 

[A mutterer]

reds discipline woes from the last few weeks might bite them here

 

[Rugby follower]

Great game to watch

 

[dru]

Is that an actual rule though? Otherwise, nah. They know they can't keep infringing.

I guess no rule, but each ref has a different tolerance to repeated infringements. A warning is good form.

 

[A mutterer]

how was that throw straight?

 

[dru]

how was that throw straight?

All night.

 

[Wilson]

Looked a lot like McReight was held back there

 

[A mutterer]

that should have been a penalty try to the reds, fucking cynical shite from the ponies

 

[Adam84]

Absolutely crap, McReight was held back

 

[dru]

Looked a lot like McReight was held back there

Definite

 

[LeCheese]

Looked a lot like McReight was held back there

Not even subtle. Unbelievable it doesn’t get a look

 

[Adam84]

Should have been a penalty try for holding back, absolutely garbage

 

[drewprint]

That no call against Iona for holding McReight back is a genuine howler.

 

[Derpus]

Should have been a penalty try for holding back, absolutely garbage

Surely not a penalty try? But a definite yellow.

 

[Wilson]

Damn, just not quite the depth to repeat last years heroics.

 

[A mutterer]

Surely not a penalty try? But a definite yellow.

how should it not been a penalty try? there was no last defender therefore noone to take out of the equation.