2022 Bledisloe Cup. Wallabies vs All Blacks

[cyclopath]

To be fair and coming to Derpus' defence, Menangle is actually a town in NSW

Dismal stopped at Wollongong on the NSFW map.

 

[Braveheart81]

Unsurprisingly, Darcy Swain has been cited.

 

[Wilson]

Swain officially cited:

https://twitter.com/i/web/status/1570607995008188416

 

[dru]

I think it's already been said that if it's time wasting during a penalty it's a scrum instead. I believe there was mention of a precedent being set during a (Welsh?) game (last year?). Haven't seen a specific reference to it in the laws though

?? It's rugby, not common law.

 

[Derpus]

?? It's rugby, not common law.

If it was common law at least you'd have a vague hope of guessing what the ref was gunna whip out next.

 

[dru]

If it was common law at least you'd have a vague hope of guessing what the ref was gunna whip out next.

Yep. BTW, France doesn't even have common law - well as I understand it. Isn't their system entirely civil law?

 

[Brumby Runner]

It was smart play by the All Blacks. They correctly predicted that we would rush to the tackle to try and prevent them competing for the ball and instead made absolutely no attempt to contest so our cleanout players had no one to bind with and just fell on the tackled player and were quite reasonably called for sealing off.

Interesting BH. Haven't seen a replay yet, but my impression was that Fa'umasili was the player penalised but he was definitely on his feet when the ruck/tackle mess disbanded. Was he ever off his feet there?

 

[Derpus]

Yep. BTW, France doesn't even have common law - well as I understand it. Isn't their system entirely civil law?

Yeah - civil law is more prescriptive where as common law is more about building law via interpretation and precedent over time. They aren't strictly bound to precedent as I understand it, but they still kind of are? It is a bit odd.

 

[Viking]

Is the 20min red card rule effective in the Rugby Championship now?

 

[dru]

There has been some (admittedly minor) chat about being down to our 3rd Captain and the inappropriateness of White as Wallaby captain. I might agree with that under normal circumstances.

This time, with the debacle from the ref, I can honestly not think of a better bloke to be Wallaby captain right then. "Who's the captain?" [willfull hope to be rid of White] "I am" [ref rolls eyes and settles for a diatribe he can't escape]. <Tell him what you really think Jake!>

Well done that captain.,

 

[John S]

Is the 20min red card rule effective in the Rugby Championship now?

No

 

[Slim 293]

Is the 20min red card rule effective in the Rugby Championship now?

Yes.

 

[Slim 293]

No

Yes.

 

[Viking]

No

Yes.

Um. ?

 

[Lyall]

.
.
Does this mean Trevor Chappell can never be mentioned again?
.
.

 

[Dan54]

It wasn't Raynal but another French twat, Pascal Gauzere

Hey this is GGR none ever had to be accurate to post here!! By geez there would be nothing to read

 

[Dan54]

.
.
Does this mean Trevor Chappell can never be mentioned again?
.
.

Well as you just mentioned him, seems yes?

 

[John S]

Yes.

Ok, I thought it wasn't I'm happy to stand corrected.

 

[Wilson]

Um. ?

For clarity, it is absolutely still in effect:

Rugby Championship to continue trial of 20-minute red card

SANZAAR has confirmed the continual trial of the 20-minute red card in the 2022 Rugby Championship.

www.rugby.com.au

 

[Slim 293]

Ok, I thought it wasn't I'm happy to stand corrected.

WR (World Rugby) didn't adopt them for all international tests, but SANZAAR have continued with it...