• Welcome to the Green and Gold Rugby forums. As you can see we've upgraded the forums to new software. Your old logon details should work, just click the 'Login' button in the top right.

Waratahs 2012

Status
Not open for further replies.
Inside Shoulder

Inside Shoulder

Nathan Sharpe (72)
Bruce Ross said:
Rob played Australian Schools in 2007 and was then elevated into Super Rugby without being given any time to learn his craft in the normal development environment of Colts or Grade Club Rugby. In his debut season he played the equivalent of just 7.2 full games and missed 30.5% of his tackle attempts. Who would have known? He had already achieved the status of “great defender”.

.
Click to expand...

This an increasing problem: kids who mature early and look the goods at 18.
A look at the guy when he was 18 would suggest he was going to struggle to get to a sustainable weight for a test 13 who played in a brutally physical way - this Stewart kid from scots looks to me (as an amateur pundit) like he has maxed out his development.
Remember the photo of Horne early this season - with huge quads and ripped: my guess is that he's on his limit.
 
Gnostic

Gnostic

Mark Ella (57)
Horne even in his current bad form is better than any other option the Tahs have at the moment to fill the 13 spot.
 
Sully

Sully

Tim Horan (67)
Staff member
I think Horne looks big because he has a smallish head for his body mass. Even now when you point out his body weight people don't believe you. I know that weights on club websites aren't completely accurate but, for backs, they are rarely lighter than the players actual weight.
Here we have a player who struggles under the burden of expectation. People believe he is a big outside centre with good attack and great defence. He's not that big. His defence is average. And he is not living up to the myth his fans have created in the hope he is the next Mortlock.
To support home need to back off and let him develop his own game. He's shown enough so far to invest more time in him. But FFS stop shoving him wallaby sides and expecting miracles.


Sent using Tapatalk on a very old phone
 
waratahjesus

waratahjesus

Greg Davis (50)
When did Horne become the next mortlock?

The guy has a great rugby brain and plays good footy, he is in a slump now for sure but it's hardly time to write him off, as mentioned above a break or some time on the bench may be the best thing for him.

As for his defense, the defensive rates have always entertained me, Horne doesn't give away alot of line breaks, (if you watch the Tahs defensive structure Alcock didn't cover shipperly so don't even mention it) he does however drop off his tacler once help arrives and fall back into the defensive line, this counts as a miss but doesn't actually impact the game as much as the statistics say.

I think the kid is just gun shy, the longer he stays injury free the better he will get.
 
Sully

Sully

Tim Horan (67)
Staff member
Don't get me wrong WJ I think he is a great talent I just think he is constantly over hyped if that's the right word.
 
Inside Shoulder

Inside Shoulder

Nathan Sharpe (72)
Smith is listed at 95kgs (6'1") - I would call that a "natural" 95 kgs: he doesn't look as if he's done as much time in the weight room as Horne (6'1"). I was kind of surprised that Anthony Fainga'a was only 90 (6'0") but it might explain his uncertain test future. AAC (Adam Ashley-Cooper) is 98kgs (6'0"). Mirling Stortlock is/was 105kg (6'3"). Brian O'Driscoll is 95 (5'10") - again a natural 95.
 
Sully

Sully

Tim Horan (67)
Staff member
You'd have to add in height to get a proper comparison. At a guess Horne is the tallest and Fainga'a is the shortest.
 
Sully

Sully

Tim Horan (67)
Staff member
Shows how you can be wrong! Here is the info off there club sites. The BMI is probably good for nothing but I thought I would chuck it in for comparison. You can change the column order by clicking the headings.

[gtable_top=800][/gtable_top][gtable_add_row_count]5[/gtable_add_row_count][gtable_add_col=string]Player[/gtable_add_col][gtable_add_col=string]Height[/gtable_add_col][gtable_add_col=string]Weight[/gtable_add_col][gtable_add_col=string]BMI[/gtable_add_col][gtable_add_data=0, 0]'A. Fainga'a'[/gtable_add_data][gtable_add_data=0, 1]'182'[/gtable_add_data][gtable_add_data=0, 2]'92'[/gtable_add_data][gtable_add_data=0, 3]'27.8'[/gtable_add_data][gtable_add_data=1, 0]'R. Horne'[/gtable_add_data][gtable_add_data=1, 1]'186'[/gtable_add_data][gtable_add_data=1, 2]'90'[/gtable_add_data][gtable_add_data=1, 3]'26'[/gtable_add_data][gtable_add_data=2, 0]'C. Smith'[/gtable_add_data][gtable_add_data=2, 1]'186'[/gtable_add_data][gtable_add_data=2, 2]'95'[/gtable_add_data][gtable_add_data=2, 3]'27.5'[/gtable_add_data][gtable_add_data=3, 0]'B. O\'Driscoll'[/gtable_add_data][gtable_add_data=3, 1]'178'[/gtable_add_data][gtable_add_data=3, 2]'95'[/gtable_add_data][gtable_add_data=3, 3]'30'[/gtable_add_data][gtable_add_data=4, 0]'A. Ashley Cooper'[/gtable_add_data][gtable_add_data=4, 1]'182'[/gtable_add_data][gtable_add_data=4, 2]'98'[/gtable_add_data][gtable_add_data=4, 3]'29.6'[/gtable_add_data][gtable_end=Player comparison]Player comparison[/gtable_end]
 
qwerty51

qwerty51

Stirling Mortlock (74)
lol at all the people doubting Horne someone should dig up that thread that was named after him when the Tahs beat the Reds 30-6 last year. Definitely in a form slump but in no way a representation of his ability, he'll be back soon.
 
BPC

BPC

Phil Hardcastle (33)
Bruce Ross said:
So if ex-international players are raving and chortling about yet another Rob Horne big hit their conclusion – and by extension that of their viewers - is inescapable. Namely, that the young bloke is a great defender. No he’s not and in fact he never was. He’s a big hit tackler without the body mass to sustain it.
Click to expand...

I am also greatly frustrated with some people, but particularly ex-players masquerading as commentators, who don't appreciate the distinction between a great tackler and a great defender.
 
waratahjesus

waratahjesus

Greg Davis (50)
Sully said:
Don't get me wrong WJ I think he is a great talent I just think he is constantly over hyped if that's the right word.
Click to expand...

I agree. The problem with hype is often that the people doing so turn on the player when he doesn't live up to the standards they set instead of allowing the players to reach there own personnel potential.

I have no doubt rob horne should his career stay relatively injury free from here will end up being seen as a tremendous player in his own right.
 
en_force_er

en_force_er

Geoff Shaw (53)
Jnor said:
Bruce, when you say 'lean muscle mass' is that as opposed to another sort of muscle mass? What's the difference?
Click to expand...

It's easy to put on 5kg of muscle along with 5kg of fat to go with it, it's hard to put on 5kg of muscle and 0kg of fat.

The diet and discipline required for "lean" muscle is insane which is why most bodybuilders/powerlifters approach their training in a bulking then cutting faze (they don't need to be fit though).
 
Bruce Ross

Bruce Ross

Ken Catchpole (46)
en_force_er said:
It's easy to put on 5kg of muscle along with 5kg of fat to go with it, it's hard to put on 5kg of muscle and 0kg of fat.

The diet and discipline required for "lean" muscle is insane which is why most bodybuilders/powerlifters approach their training in a bulking then cutting faze (they don't need to be fit though).
Click to expand...

As you would appreciate, en_force_er, obviously when I was writing about "lean muscle mass" I meant "lean" in terms of what is appropriate for a rugby player, i.e., adding 5kg while retaining basically the same skinfold measurements.
 
Hawko

Hawko

Tony Shaw (54)
qwerty51 said:
lol at all the people doubting Horne someone should dig up that thread that was named after him when the Tahs beat the Reds 30-6 last year. Definitely in a form slump but in no way a representation of his ability, he'll be back soon.
Click to expand...

Yeah, but the Tahs have to pick their game up NOW, not soon. Another two or three losses and we are gone for the season.

I have always thought that Horne has all the skills. The day he played Conrad Smith, the worlds current best 13, and absolutely owned him proved he has the skills. But he's had six games so far this season and looked a shadow of his former self. The question of whether we can afford to leave him at 13 when our season is on the line in the hope he might come good is what is pertinent.

My opinion is to bite the bullet and give him time to regain his form from the bench. With all the injuries we have the only way I can see to do that is to either bring in a specialist winger and move AAC (Adam Ashley-Cooper) to 13 or to put AAC (Adam Ashley-Cooper) at fullback, bring Foley in to 10 and move Barnes and Carter out one.

Let us all agree that Horne is either woefully out of form or never was any good anyway. Doesn't matter which. The question is what to do with the TEAM, that is the first priority. Lose the next two games and we are gone for the season (very likely). We would depend on other teams in the conference losing other games to make top spot in the conference, the only way I think we'll make it. So....., given the situation and its criticality, what should we do?
 
fatprop

fatprop

George Gregan (70)
Staff member
I thought Horne was better against the Chiefs, it was an incremental improvement, but ...... better
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top