• Welcome to the Green and Gold Rugby forums. As you can see we've upgraded the forums to new software. Your old logon details should work, just click the 'Login' button in the top right.

Search results

  1. Seagull Butler

    Southern Inland Rugby 2022

    Sanction line for a Goal Line drop out is the 5 metre line. Shown in the picture accompanying Law 12.
  2. Seagull Butler

    Subbies 2021

    Don't let anyone tell you that - the population of the Central West has been growing every year since at least 2006, and this applies also to the 20-34 yr olds which has also grown as a group. It's leading to ridiculous house prices & no rentals in those same markets. Your comment about...
  3. Seagull Butler

    Subbies 2021

    I wonder whether league participation numbers at an adult level could possibly have something to do with the money instead? Subbies participation seems to have gone downhill since that little caveat was introduced. And League does it at least in country rugby - look at Group 10 (picking this...
  4. Seagull Butler

    Sydney Subbies 2020

    Considering we've been told for years that the finals gate takings are an important source of income for Subbies and that this is why only fields with a suitable fence are considered to host, the decision can't have been an easy one to make.
  5. Seagull Butler

    Sydney Subbies 2019

    Keep it positive there Alan Jones! Maybe instead rename as The Potential for Best New Fence - this way clubs without a fence can compete, not just clubs whose fence is not optimal.
  6. Seagull Butler

    Sydney Subbies 2019

    Ok, so from someone that wasn't just an interested observer: The call was rough (First time I've seen it called this season, let alone in the game with 6 seconds left) but we shouldn't have let them get back to that close to us in the first place. Whether it was right or not I don't know as I...
  7. Seagull Butler

    Sydney Subbies 2019

    I agree on this one. I don't think the status quo is working, but I also don't believe that prohibition would work as a way to improve a situation. Maybe make it so clubs could increase the number of Education Grants (+ max value) that can be given to colts players, maybe make it that this...
  8. Seagull Butler

    Sydney Subbies 2019

    And like to hang around and have a drink afterwards as well. I disagree with you on this Pfitzy - punishing the players at clubs that do get 4th (5/6/7th) grade players is not the way to grow the sport. In our case (which is the only one I can talk of), most of these boys are either long time...
  9. Seagull Butler

    Sydney Subbies 2019

    Let's play devils advocate then, could re-allowing player payments/subsidies help re-attract kids from league/afl/soccer (i.e. all the non-amateur sports that are actually doing better than Rugby)? If we are going to look at their structure, lets look at their entire structure.
  10. Seagull Butler

    Sydney Subbies 2019

    Ok, well I'll bite just to show how far off you are (aaand I haven't posted in a while). Our 1st Grade win on the weekend used 17 players - 15 who played in Rd 1 or 2. (13 1st Grade, 1 who started in Seconds against Forest last time and the other played in Thirds). Of the final two players...
  11. Seagull Butler

    Sydney Subbies 2019

    Sorry to disappoint but tomorrow is our Back to Boronia Day rather than Ladies Day. The sideline view is expected to be substantially different.
  12. Seagull Butler

    Sydney Subbies 2019

    Kids are relevant to footy, games where you've had no sleep the night before without alcoholic inducement, waking up at 5.30am on game day, not wanting to train more than once a week to spend time with them, having a legitimate dad bod, running after the toddler all morning while they constantly...
  13. Seagull Butler

    Sydney Subbies 2019

    Or indeed run the club, of our playing committee members this year, over half haven't started 1st grade this year.
  14. Seagull Butler

    Sydney Subbies 2019

    I would say it only appears unhealthy due to the troubles other clubs have of attracting players. Trying to force these extras to play elsewhere would only result in the majority of them leaving the game, so you can't attack the clubs themselves for actually providing the teams for these gents...
  15. Seagull Butler

    Sydney Subbies 2019

    No, it was something that the ref and both touchies missed last year - admittedly play had moved on near the try line so they had a reasonable excuse. Understand that you weren't talking about the extremes, I was more trying to point out that the restrictions on rough play has made it more...
  16. Seagull Butler

    Sydney Subbies 2019

    There's cheap shots and then there's intentionally stamping on someone's nut-sack. And since Subbies have made mid-range striking 6 weeks, you can no longer deal with fwits on the field.
  17. Seagull Butler

    Sydney Subbies 2019

    Even with a dedicated home ground, we always have to factor in the Food & Wine and Moocooboola Festival's as to our ground availability. So assume the case for other clubs as well. We have 3 of the last 4 games at home which while great for ending the season, does make spreading social events a...
  18. Seagull Butler

    Sydney Subbies 2019

    Technically he should be fine as he wasn't a professional Rugby Union player in last 2 years & hadn't played NRC or Shute last year. The only issue would be the overseas player transfer I guess as he last played rugby for Fiji?
  19. Seagull Butler

    Sydney Subbies 2019

    Without restarting the argument of who did/didn't pay, the problem with going back far enough is that you enter territory where teams were able to spend money on the players who helped them move up/stay up divisions. It would be harder I imagine for a Div 4 team to use a 'prestige' argument...
  20. Seagull Butler

    Sydney Subbies 2018

    Are you looking at a 13 week season or a 26 week season? And if not home/away then imagine the discussion if Colleagues copped Blueys and HAC away... However - conference Div 1 - then play each other twice (12 games) before having a league finals series (Week 1 - E1 v W4, E2 v W3 etc, top two...
Top