RWC: NZL v ARG (Wembley Stadium) Pool C
- Thread starter waiopehu oldboy
- Start date
- Status
Chris McCracken
Jim Clark (26)
They are really gutting it out.
What a great game of Rugby. Really worth getting out of bed for.
Relance
Herbert Moran (7)
Right, like that Paul O'Connell kick to Dave Kearney's head?
Tordah
Dave Cowper (27)
the plastic paddy
John Solomon (38)
No I was thinking of Donncha O'Callaghans missed kick near an Ulster players head that saw him get two weeks.
the plastic paddy
John Solomon (38)
As the Puma's four scored the try Carter's boot made contact with his head. What Carter's boot was doing there God knows but he would be cited in the NH.
Relance
Herbert Moran (7)
My comment was ironic. You're blaming Carter for what looked more like tripping than anything else and talk about how that would have been cited in the NH. POC's monster kick fits your definition of a "reckless, dangerous" kick yet it wasn't cited, let alone penalised by the ref, which is the only thing that could have happened at this stage anyway.
the plastic paddy
John Solomon (38)
Since when did you trip someone up by the head? EDIT and the POC incident happened well over two years ago when Schmidt was still the Leinster coach.
mxyzptlk
Colin Windon (37)
EDIT: Already posted.
Iñaki Zubizarreta
Herbert Moran (7)
There were only 10.000 argentines at the stadium (there are 89.000 people in total). Richie is not beloved anywhere out of NZ.
the plastic paddy
John Solomon (38)
The priority given to head injuries has changed quite fundamentally since that incident. Possibly it was that incident that precipitated it because, ironically, Joe Schmidt kicked up such a fuss about it. There have been a few incidents of players getting banned in the NH for incidents just like Carter today. Any contact with the head is meant to be a priority at the RWC.
the plastic paddy
John Solomon (38)
I think he is a brilliant player, certainly the best I have seen and a lot of the abuse he gets is pure jealousy. That said, time is just starting to catch up with the man and the clever/ cynical bits and pieces that have made him so brilliant are starting to get spotted. NZ are not the force of old.
mxyzptlk
Colin Windon (37)
I'd like to know what those are, because I can't think of anyone who's been banned for incidental or accidental contact to the head, only reckless or deliberate contact.
Who knows, maybe Carter's incident will be reviewed and he'll be cited.
the plastic paddy
John Solomon (38)
Donncha O'Callaghan is one that immediately stings to mind. It was unintentional and he didn't even make contact but picked up a ban. Carter's foot moved towards your man's head, he made contact. I would say that is reckless. Not intentional I am sure but reckless none the less. I think he could be cited and pick up one of these new warnings rather than a ban because I would have said it was a penalty/ yellow card offence, but I think he should be cited.
teach
Trevor Allan (34)
Really? I thought deep down everyone loves him and pretends to hate him on game day.
the plastic paddy
John Solomon (38)
No reason to hate the man, I think that little trip today is the dirtiest thing I have ever seen the man do. He plays right on the edge of legality but he is not even close to a cheap shot merchant. Wonderful player but not as good as he was.
Dan54
Tim Horan (67)
Well that was a typical first up effort by the ABs, they looked rusty as hell for a while, but hell of a lot of credit to Argies who also helped make them look that way. Thought the Argies gave everything they had, showed in last 10-15 minutes, so game went more or less as expected, although ABs could of picked up a couple more tries without having butterfingers. Thought Barnes reffed game well, though he tends to put his whistle away in most tests towrds end of game. All in all scratchy performance by ABs but I happy banking the win, and expect improvements as WC progresses.
- Status