TRC2021 - All Blacks v Springboks @ Townsville 25/09
- Thread starter Pfitzy
- Start date
Jeffrey
Chris McKivat (8)
Over and over again, the ABs show 2 major weaknesses, which are both related.
1) Is the forward armwrestle - when the game is about brutal physicality, about making metres in heavy traffic, in stopping bulldozers, in clearing big bodies off rucks, the teams that are big, powerful, and urgent that pull the ABs into an arm wrestle get very good gains. As a rugby nation, we have always been about speed, skill, and fitness - hopefully at some point we will accept that you need a balance, you need some meatheads in there.
2) is the rush defense - which since the first 1st B&I test we have never found an answer for. The problem is that many people believe you beat the rush with kicks or width. Empirically, width almost never works. It only sounds good in theory. But the rush defense fans in which makes the wide ball incredibly risky. Kicks do work, but you can't kick away everything.
It actually still comes back to making metres in heavy contact, both as a runner off 9 (and not 10) and midfielders being able to drag the advantage line further upfield. As we all know, that 1 metre makes the difference in alignment, which is everything at this level.
Jordie Barrett excellent. Blackadder worked hard.
A lot of the forwards have been inaccurate, including Brodie and Moody, their experienced duo. Laulala and Ioane are mentally not ready for such contests. Good test for Ardie as captain. Scott Barrett - I don't know why, is not a confident option at lineout.
I feel for George Bridge. He's been shocking. But my quibble with him is not the dropped balls - it's that as a winger he doesn't have X-factor. He's not particularly quick, he's not powerful, and he's not a great stepper. he's a guy who does the basics very well (usually) but it's not what the ABs need I don't think.
This is a big test for Beauden. I always thought this was his biggest question mark. Sure he is ridiculously skillful. But can he control a chess match, where sometimes your forwards are outmuscled? It doesn't need to be run run run every time. It's a big test especially because Perenara isn't a Smith - he doesn't quite offer the tactical kicking and marshalling and organisation.
Finally - I think the Boks will run out of gas in the second half. It's been a brutal season for them. Many of them started with their European clubs this time last year and played a lot of games in a physically demanding season. They then had to go through all the hassle getting back, had a huge battle with the Lions, and then travelling over here. Some of their blokes like Handre, DUnae, and Lood were out for long periods with injury. And they are missing Kolbe.
1) Is the forward armwrestle - when the game is about brutal physicality, about making metres in heavy traffic, in stopping bulldozers, in clearing big bodies off rucks, the teams that are big, powerful, and urgent that pull the ABs into an arm wrestle get very good gains. As a rugby nation, we have always been about speed, skill, and fitness - hopefully at some point we will accept that you need a balance, you need some meatheads in there.
2) is the rush defense - which since the first 1st B&I test we have never found an answer for. The problem is that many people believe you beat the rush with kicks or width. Empirically, width almost never works. It only sounds good in theory. But the rush defense fans in which makes the wide ball incredibly risky. Kicks do work, but you can't kick away everything.
It actually still comes back to making metres in heavy contact, both as a runner off 9 (and not 10) and midfielders being able to drag the advantage line further upfield. As we all know, that 1 metre makes the difference in alignment, which is everything at this level.
Jordie Barrett excellent. Blackadder worked hard.
A lot of the forwards have been inaccurate, including Brodie and Moody, their experienced duo. Laulala and Ioane are mentally not ready for such contests. Good test for Ardie as captain. Scott Barrett - I don't know why, is not a confident option at lineout.
I feel for George Bridge. He's been shocking. But my quibble with him is not the dropped balls - it's that as a winger he doesn't have X-factor. He's not particularly quick, he's not powerful, and he's not a great stepper. he's a guy who does the basics very well (usually) but it's not what the ABs need I don't think.
This is a big test for Beauden. I always thought this was his biggest question mark. Sure he is ridiculously skillful. But can he control a chess match, where sometimes your forwards are outmuscled? It doesn't need to be run run run every time. It's a big test especially because Perenara isn't a Smith - he doesn't quite offer the tactical kicking and marshalling and organisation.
Finally - I think the Boks will run out of gas in the second half. It's been a brutal season for them. Many of them started with their European clubs this time last year and played a lot of games in a physically demanding season. They then had to go through all the hassle getting back, had a huge battle with the Lions, and then travelling over here. Some of their blokes like Handre, DUnae, and Lood were out for long periods with injury. And they are missing Kolbe.
Last edited:
Up the Guts
Steve Williams (59)
Etzebeth is stupidly jacked. Surely on the jab.
Up the Guts
Steve Williams (59)
Merhts not said anything for about 10 minutes
KOB1987
Rod McCall (65)
Was talking about that with my kids before. The guns, WTF.
Derpus
George Gregan (70)
Rock, paper, scissors
KOB1987
Rod McCall (65)
Last comment from a kiwi on here even was about half an hour ago.
PhilClinton
Geoff Shaw (53)
Why the fark do the Boks kick the ball away all the time. Counter attack especially. Stupid play.