• Welcome to the Green and Gold Rugby forums. As you can see we've upgraded the forums to new software. Your old logon details should work, just click the 'Login' button in the top right.

Waratahs vs Chiefs Super Rugby Rd 10, Fri 19 April 2013

Status
Not open for further replies.

Braveheart81

Will Genia (78)
Staff member
$100 worth of piss in an hour-and-a-half? Even the members of the Board would be flat out getting through that much.

And if you did manage to sink $100 worth you'd be highly unlikely to "take in all the on-field action".

No disrespect to the Saltram people but "valued at $100"? If you go to Reims - and it would probably take about the same time to get there as it will to get to Allianz on the 19th - you could go to Veuve Clicquot where a "Tasting and Tour is 26 euro per person and lasts about 1.5 hours." Or if you were back packing you could visit Mumm where the "Tour and Tasting is 10 euro."
.

They were banking on you attending Bruce.

$50 of the $100 value was purely the opportunity to meet you.
 

Ash

Michael Lynagh (62)
Been there, done that in Champagne. Can't remember which champagne one we went on, think it was Veuve. Unfortunately there wasn't much champagne tasted, most of it was tour of the (interesting) cellars.

Did it as part of a larger tour which included small champagne making wineries. Bought some bottles of the best champange I have had for 15 to 20 euro.

The wine tasting sounds like they want to get you drunk to pressure you into buying their overpriced vino. I'm sure Lindommer will be happy to do you some nice deals if you want some wine from smaller makers and you are into that sort of thing.
 

Braveheart81

Will Genia (78)
Staff member
Bump.

Hopefully the Tahs are well rested after the bye and hungry to put in a massive game against the reigning champs.

This week should see the return of TPN and presumably Palu will be in the run on side.

I wonder if we'll see a change at halfback? Let's hope so!
 

fatprop

George Gregan (70)
Staff member
$100 worth of piss in an hour-and-a-half? Even the members of the Board would be flat out getting through that much.

And if you did manage to sink $100 worth you'd be highly unlikely to "take in all the on-field action".

No disrespect to the Saltram people but "valued at $100"? If you go to Reims - and it would probably take about the same time to get there as it will to get to Allianz on the 19th - you could go to Veuve Clicquot where a "Tasting and Tour is 26 euro per person and lasts about 1.5 hours." Or if you were back packing you could visit Mumm where the "Tour and Tasting is 10 euro."
.

It is "free", as for the $100 "value", it depends what they are opening.

At Veuve Clicquot there may be a 26 euro tour, but it depends on what they are opening and tasting, the one I went on the tour was interesting and the 20 minutes of tasting was nice, but there was no vintage tastings without further charge
 

fatprop

George Gregan (70)
Staff member
Not very confident about this game.

The Chiefs will dominate the tackles and are brilliant on counter while the Tahs are average in transition

I expect us to get close at times, go through the phase, run out of units, turn over the ball and they score too often
 

rugbysmartarse

Alan Cameron (40)
agree fatprop, unless the team has worked hard on defensive realignment from turnovers we will get eaten alive. If the big lads muscle up there could be space around the rucks, but I predict this will be another Hurricanes game, where we play well in patches but give away too many easy points
 

Richo

John Thornett (49)
$100 worth of piss in an hour-and-a-half? Even the members of the Board would be flat out getting through that much.

And if you did manage to sink $100 worth you'd be highly unlikely to "take in all the on-field action".

No disrespect to the Saltram people but "valued at $100"? If you go to Reims - and it would probably take about the same time to get there as it will to get to Allianz on the 19th - you could go to Veuve Clicquot where a "Tasting and Tour is 26 euro per person and lasts about 1.5 hours." Or if you were back packing you could visit Mumm where the "Tour and Tasting is 10 euro."
.

Not sure about that Mumm tour being good value. Is it Dean or Greg?
 

Richo

John Thornett (49)
Not very confident about this game.

The Chiefs will dominate the tackles and are brilliant on counter while the Tahs are average in transition

I expect us to get close at times, go through the phase, run out of units, turn over the ball and they score too often

That's my thought too. The Reds shut down a few great Chiefs opportunities and got a bit lucky on others (that dropped ball after Cruden's soccer kick, for example). Then they got a big enough lead to choke the Chiefs out. I don't think the Tahs can put the points on OR show the stinginess in defense.
 

fatprop

George Gregan (70)
Staff member
That's my thought too. The Reds shut down a few great Chiefs opportunities and got a bit lucky on others (that dropped ball after Cruden's soccer kick, for example). Then they got a big enough lead to choke the Chiefs out. I don't think the Tahs can put the points on OR show the stinginess in defense.

yeah, Link knows how to beat the Chiefs, he gives them nothing, plays it tight, mauls and goes set piece to set piece where possible with lots of field position

I just can't see the Tahs doing that as they are still afraid of their home crowd
 

Rob42

John Solomon (38)
Conversely, I think our scrum will be stronger than the Reds, and if Hooper can get his head in plenty of Chiefs rucks, he should be able to slow them down, which was an important part of the Reds plan. The Tahs backline has been able to break lines with direct running this season, so's there's hope.

I still worry about our ability to dominate attacking rucks though.
 

Richo

John Thornett (49)
yeah, Link knows how to beat the Chiefs, he gives them nothing, plays it tight, mauls and goes set piece to set piece where possible with lots of field position

I just can't see the Tahs doing that as they are still afraid of their home crowd

The Reds are very, very good at capitalising on tight play and set pieces to execute exciting moves. The Tahs have shown the potential to do this in fits and starts this season, but -- as you say -- whether they have the patience or purpose to play a bit of field position is a different story.
 

fatprop

George Gregan (70)
Staff member
Conversely, I think our scrum will be stronger than the Reds, and if Hooper can get his head in plenty of Chiefs rucks, he should be able to slow them down, which was an important part of the Reds plan. The Tahs backline has been able to break lines with direct running this season, so's there's hope.

I still worry about our ability to dominate attacking rucks though.

This is a massive test for Robinson, Ben Tameifuna is just massive and just makes loose heads collapse under his weight if they get their engagement wrong as they can't hold the guy up
 

Hugh Jarse

Rocky Elsom (76)
Staff member
Every match this season is important and a potential turning point, but one gets the feeling that after a week off to review and consolidate lessons learned and opportunities missed so far this season, this outing against the Tribe will define the season for the Tahs.

The Tribe will be rueing their missed opportunities against the Reds where they were comprehensively out coached, and they will be out to demonstrate that last weeks performance was a one off.

One has to assume that that the Tahs coaching team have done their homework on the Chiefs (as Link clearly did), and it will be up to the players to execute their downfall at the SFS on Friday night.

Failure to execute an appropriate gameplan, or the absence of any reasonable gameplan will be an Emperor's New Clothes moment - when it is undeniably pointed out, for all to see, that the 2013 Tahs hype is just that.
 

Rob42

John Solomon (38)
Every match this season is important and a potential turning point, but one gets the feeling that after a week off to review and consolidate lessons learned and opportunities missed so far this season, this outing against the Tribe will define the season for the Tahs.

The Tribe will be rueing their missed opportunities against the Reds where they were comprehensively out coached, and they will be out to demonstrate that last weeks performance was a one off.

One has to assume that that the Tahs coaching team have done their homework on the Chiefs (as Link clearly did), and it will be up to the players to execute their downfall at the SFS on Friday night.

Failure to execute an appropriate gameplan, or the absence of any reasonable gameplan will be an Emperor's New Clothes moment - when it is undeniably pointed out, for all to see, that the 2013 Tahs hype is just that.

Yes, the embarassing performance against the Brumbies early in the season could, viewing hindsight with rose-coloured glasses, be seen as a team struggling to adapt to a new gameplan, since the following performances have been an improvement. A similar effort at this point in the season will be harder to accept, especially after a week off.

Mind you, Cheika has been pushing the "it won't happen overnight, but it will happen" line pretty hard.
 

Inside Shoulder

Nathan Sharpe (72)
I think that the Reds should take the 2 points if the Chiefs win: they're victory will have stung the Chiefs and its hard to see them not coming out and punishing the Tahs.
On the other hand....
 

Hugh Jarse

Rocky Elsom (76)
Staff member
And by now there should be elements of " it happening" starting to be evident. Friday will be their chance. We can't go on living in dreamland and hearing good words.

We need evidence, and we need it now. As I have said, evidence could be of either a well thought out gameplan OR great execution of a average gameplan.

Poor execution of an average gameplan and we are back in the Hickey and Foley days.
 

Ash

Michael Lynagh (62)
The difference is that Link changes the Reds game plan from week to week based on the team they are playing. The Reds tried to take it to the Chiefs forwards. Very different game plan from what the Tahs are trying to work out.

If you try to play fast and loose with the Canes then they will typically burn you on the counter, or even when they get a little space when they get some good ball.

The new Tahs style is at risk of forcing it wide too early, not getting enough bodies to their own breaks and giving away too many easy turnovers. They need to attack the Chiefs forwards first. Problem is that Chieka seems too focused with getting his own style right fist. Against the Chiefs either it can work and look great, or the Tahs give away too much ball and get shredded on the counter.
 

JSRF10

Dick Tooth (41)
I can see something similar to the Canes match; we'll score some nice tries and create a lot of chances. However we'll just be too poor defending the Chiefs counter attack and we'll lose by around 10, Cheks will come out and say we're a work in progress, when in reality we've been making the same mistakes every game this season.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top