Melbourne Rebels vs Brumbies match thread
- Thread starter Brumby Jack
- Start date
- Status
aussie1st
Alfred Walker (16)
That was rubbishing deciding a game like that. Anyway congrats to the Rebels nice to see them bounce back after last week and show they can be competitive. As for the Brumbies that was shocking. Coleman again a stand out, Colby was great when he came on, Mcabe again good, not much to say about the rest though.
G
GC
Guest
Fine defence and brilliant kicking for the Rebels. Perfect game plan with the available players. Top coaching from Macqueen and captaincy from Morty.
R
Richard D. James
Guest
Congrats Rebel, well done.
I'm pissed off at the Brumbies, but not as much as I normally would be when they lose.
How can you not be happy for the Rebels?
I'm pissed off at the Brumbies, but not as much as I normally would be when they lose.
How can you not be happy for the Rebels?
T
TOCC
Guest
Well done Melbourne!!
Hard loss for the Brumbies, but thats the nature of the beast, they really shouldn't have ever allowed the Rebels to be within 2pt with only 60sec remaining.
Hard loss for the Brumbies, but thats the nature of the beast, they really shouldn't have ever allowed the Rebels to be within 2pt with only 60sec remaining.
R
Richard D. James
Guest
Yeah, as usual the refs calls even out in the end. Brumbies get the try from a forward pass, Rebels get a cheap penalty.
nathan
Darby Loudon (17)
What a rubbish game. Big shout out to Kaplan for yet again, ruining a game of rugby. I never saw the guy play an advantage, just stop things. To decide the game with a lightweight touch from Ma'afu is just a joke.
McCabe, Vaea, Coleman and Finger all played well. Gits had another mediocre game and To'omua unfortunately added nothing when he came on. Disappointing for the Brumbies, as much as it's great for Melbourne to win...the brumbies didn't need to hand away a game like it's charity.
McCabe, Vaea, Coleman and Finger all played well. Gits had another mediocre game and To'omua unfortunately added nothing when he came on. Disappointing for the Brumbies, as much as it's great for Melbourne to win...the brumbies didn't need to hand away a game like it's charity.
Gnostic
Mark Ella (57)
My thoughts on the game:-
1) Kaplan is a crime against Rugby. A worse ref there is not anywhere to be found. He has even begun to make shit up - Delve not releasing the ball when he was not tackled. I agree he should be refused entry to Australia for anything to do with Rugby.
2) Brumbies very poor again this week. The issues that were evident last week came back to haunt them. They rely almost totaly on individuals to get them over the gain line, and if a Coleman, AAC (Adam Ashley-Cooper) or Mcabe doesn't do it they struggle to make the gain line. Notice that they had what 80% of the ball and did two parts of SFA with it. Yes the Rebels defended well, take nothing away from them for that but the Brumbies offered little in attack.
3) Very impressed with Ita Vaea (sp) - run very similar line to Willie O - IMO.
4) I was a sceptic of Huxley at 12 but he played a very good game in conjunction with Cipriani. Vuna looked much better on the wing than at centre.
1) Kaplan is a crime against Rugby. A worse ref there is not anywhere to be found. He has even begun to make shit up - Delve not releasing the ball when he was not tackled. I agree he should be refused entry to Australia for anything to do with Rugby.
2) Brumbies very poor again this week. The issues that were evident last week came back to haunt them. They rely almost totaly on individuals to get them over the gain line, and if a Coleman, AAC (Adam Ashley-Cooper) or Mcabe doesn't do it they struggle to make the gain line. Notice that they had what 80% of the ball and did two parts of SFA with it. Yes the Rebels defended well, take nothing away from them for that but the Brumbies offered little in attack.
3) Very impressed with Ita Vaea (sp) - run very similar line to Willie O - IMO.
4) I was a sceptic of Huxley at 12 but he played a very good game in conjunction with Cipriani. Vuna looked much better on the wing than at centre.
Novocastrian
Herbert Moran (7)
Only caught the last 15 minutes or so, but was impressed with how both teams were still throwing themselves into it all the way to the end, still seemed to be pretty physical even at that late stage. Terrible call for the penalty, but fair enough given the forward pass for Speight's try.
Good to see Mortlock still charging at the line.
Good to see Mortlock still charging at the line.
Sandpit Fan
Nev Cottrell (35)
WorkingClassRugger
David Codey (61)
1) Kaplan was dire as per usual. This is a real issue in Rugby and could potentially turn people away. The Ref has too much influence on the result. Don't know what can be done to rectify this but it must be addressed.
2) Vaea looks a good prospect. Give him time but if he continues to play with such strength he'll provide a serious threat to Palu come Wallaby selections. He is Aus eligible right?
Ash
Michael Lynagh (62)
By those stats the Brumbies should have put on 50.
68% possession, 61% territory, 9 line breaks, 8 mins in Rebels 22, Rebels had 35 missed tackles
We are seeing why Alexander was the top Brumbies try scorer past season as they failed to take their chances
The odds for Friend being the first coach sacked must be going nuts.
68% possession, 61% territory, 9 line breaks, 8 mins in Rebels 22, Rebels had 35 missed tackles
We are seeing why Alexander was the top Brumbies try scorer past season as they failed to take their chances
The odds for Friend being the first coach sacked must be going nuts.
C
chriss555
Guest
Congrats Rebels !! strong 2nd half defence and awesome Crowd "
- Status