Goosestep
Syd Malcolm (24)
Grow up
NSW AAGPS 2023
- Thread starter Joker
- Start date
- Status
hogieslammer
Frank Row (1)
Looks like Shore put up a fight against a View team that was still recovering from the weekend. Well done to them, unfortunate that it’s marred by controversial calls. I’m sure they’ll celebrate over the long weekend
Taralga
Stan Wickham (3)
Agree - just not Joey's year - they are close but just not happening at the moment.
The Ghost of Raelene
Andrew Slack (58)
You wouldn’t judging by how they carry on.
This comp is so even at the moment. Kings getting it done has it almost put away now.
Up and In
Allen Oxlade (6)
TGoR, I have always been on your side with everything you've posted, but your comment on the ref "he needs his head read" is disappointing from someone who's always been objective (from my angle anyway).
View2024prems
Banned
Also last post before I probs get banned. But can someone explain when the 7 for view got carded why didn’t the penalty take place where it happen? Why did it got moved forward to where last play was.
The Ghost of Raelene
Andrew Slack (58)
I try not to go after Refs. I’ve actually said a lot have been positive this year but when it’s bad it’s bad and in Rugby it has such a massive impact on the sport unfortunately.
Probably harsh on the language but it’s been said.
It’s a good effort from Shore following a big loss. Coaches would be proud
View2024prems
Banned
Like I can agree shore played very well probably one of their best this year. And it was pretty scrappy by view. It just frustrating that on a couple of questionable decisions can decide a game.
RemainingInTheGame
Peter Burge (5)
I'm watching the Shore v View game on the back of this thread.
Can someone post some times for all of these ref incidents.
I'd usually dismiss as sour grapes but the volumes of posts has me wanting to judge for myself.
(And that is one of NSWRRA most experienced active refs).
Can someone post some times for all of these ref incidents.
I'd usually dismiss as sour grapes but the volumes of posts has me wanting to judge for myself.
(And that is one of NSWRRA most experienced active refs).
Attachments
propsarespeedy
Billy Sheehan (19)
Scots 29 - 13 Newington, great game. Scots started 10-0 down and came back really well running hard in the forward pack and scoring some great tries through the backs. Some quality defence was another reason scot's we're Standout players for me would be Jay mckenzie, Will Guilfoyle and Harry Gianoutsos
Last edited:
The Ghost of Raelene
Andrew Slack (58)
Scots Boys showing up to Long Weekend long lunch following the W.
Backintheolddays
Bill Watson (15)
Sounds like some Cluch in store tonight. While all debate about Shore v View ref what the hell is going on with Scots and New? Form book out the window. While a sky blue supporter glad the cerise and blue showed up. Great even comp this year.
TheRugbysmoker185
Allen Oxlade (6)
Shore played a good game, a win for shore is very good.
Backintheolddays
Bill Watson (15)
And great effort to Joeys 2nds. Look forward to the final round, could be premiership decider.
Goosestep
Syd Malcolm (24)
Joeys have struggled all year (bar the first half/ game against Scot’s) to turn large amounts of possession & set piece dominance throughout the game into points. They are definitely missing players who are finishers .
They Only scored one try today, and that was through the forwards.
I won’t whinge about the ref like many view supporters are doing but…….another factor was kings late game defence was poor.
Wristman
Alfred Walker (16)
New and disturbing territory for Joeys.....mid season without a win and bottom of the 1st XV table......one point adrift of Shore.
I do believe they've been unlucky though and to take them lightly in return matches would be unwise.
A lot of close matches and whilst it is clearly going to be Kings year 32 points has been the biggest winning margin.
Good for the GPS competition....a period without outright dominance by any school.
Kings, Joeys, View, Scots and Newington have all taken turns at the top since 2010.
I do believe they've been unlucky though and to take them lightly in return matches would be unwise.
A lot of close matches and whilst it is clearly going to be Kings year 32 points has been the biggest winning margin.
Good for the GPS competition....a period without outright dominance by any school.
Kings, Joeys, View, Scots and Newington have all taken turns at the top since 2010.
View lost to a better team. View were their own enemy. Dropped ball, ill disciplined, poor tackling and tactically out smarted and did not play their own game which has served them well. Yes, I believe they had a lag from last week but that should not happen from a champion team and unfortunately, this is not one. Shore played their game, simple yet effective and played the ref well ( you can do that !!). Congrats Shore !
New were very dumb. kicked too often and straight to the 15 who was the most dangerous player on the field. Why kick to him ? Dumb tactics
( coaches or players ?). Blew their chance to go second with View losing and can't see them recovering to challenge for the title. Scots played well enough to win with some good phases yet their backline still needs work. Individual brilliance got them over the line.
Kings are the leaders going into Rd 2 and champion teams win when they don't play well and play tough towin away at Joeys. Well done and they have 1 hand on the trophy. Joeys played with lots of heart, probably played their toughest today yet came second. No luck, just not good enough.
Can't see Kings being beaten ( obvious thing to say ) but they are a complete team with smart coaches and smart players ib key positions.
Refs are Refs. You play what's in front, cop the bad calls and turn things around.
New were very dumb. kicked too often and straight to the 15 who was the most dangerous player on the field. Why kick to him ? Dumb tactics
( coaches or players ?). Blew their chance to go second with View losing and can't see them recovering to challenge for the title. Scots played well enough to win with some good phases yet their backline still needs work. Individual brilliance got them over the line.
Kings are the leaders going into Rd 2 and champion teams win when they don't play well and play tough towin away at Joeys. Well done and they have 1 hand on the trophy. Joeys played with lots of heart, probably played their toughest today yet came second. No luck, just not good enough.
Can't see Kings being beaten ( obvious thing to say ) but they are a complete team with smart coaches and smart players ib key positions.
Refs are Refs. You play what's in front, cop the bad calls and turn things around.
- Status