eastman
Arch Winning (36)
He's a very decent Shute Shield player but at best should be depth for a Super Rugby franchise. The fact he is starting and close to the captaincy is a sad indictment on the Waratahs.
Waratahs 2021
- Thread starter RugbyReg
- Start date
He's a very decent Shute Shield player but at best should be depth for a Super Rugby franchise. The fact he is starting and close to the captaincy is a sad indictment on the Waratahs.
eastman
Arch Winning (36)
Taqele N was a horrendous defender and his workrate was considerably worse than Mark's.
I doubt he will ever be a great (or even good) defender but as long as there are marginal improvements and he actually becomes an attacking weapon - that's good enough.
They all do, happy to look for an upgrade, I just don't know of any in our price range
Rob42
John Solomon (38)
I think it's hard to complain about Whittaker's attack, it's sometimes looked pedestrian but it's been effective and improving. I don't think he's keen to be head coach, but I'd like him to be part of the future coaching team - they need that connection with someone who has a great Tahs history
Blackadder
Desmond Connor (43)
I would be happy for a youngster to take his place and spend the money elsewhere as the Tahs have had him for years and he has done little.
Blackadder
Desmond Connor (43)
He has been here as attack coach for over three years. He either has the endless, pointless kicking that does little or plays hot potato football. Teams read it and mark it.
Rob42
John Solomon (38)
Yeah, not the NZ teams, it seems. Tahs have scored more points in SRTT than the other AU teams, or Chiefs
Jimmy_Crouch
Ken Catchpole (46)
The attack has the same issues as the Wobs did under Cheika, it is overly ambitious with players not ready to play so open and loose............................................ and then it breaks down and we get murdered/out numbered/run over. They need to pull their heads in, play with more structure and just limit errors.
It always comes down to the set piece, the defence and kick/chase to create the opportunities
Blackadder
Desmond Connor (43)
Whole country full of players to look for a player. Newsome has had several years and has gone backwards
Blackadder
Desmond Connor (43)
Hence why time for new Coaching staff across the board
Jimmy_Crouch
Ken Catchpole (46)
Blackadder
Desmond Connor (43)
Don't need to, just don't need to keep a crap player. Hence the term recruitment. You know that dirty word the Tahs struggle with
Newsome one of the most experienced players in a young squad. Good leadership qualities and only just turned 26 so his best years still ahead of him. i wouldn't be cutting him just yet. Also struggling to see the connection between Penny and Newsome?
Gibson signed him and played him in front of more senior wingers including Curtis Rona so clearly they see something in him
Gibson signed him and played him in front of more senior wingers including Curtis Rona so clearly they see something in him
Blackadder
Desmond Connor (43)
Being experienced he should be playing better. Being 26 he should show some improvement.
Penney made him vice captain despite being an average player and doesn't lead by example or offer much. He then named him Captain whilst playing on the wing and struggling to offer anything.
Don't get me started on Gibson
I hope they move him on too. I can't handle another season of Blackadder talking about it.
Blackadder
Desmond Connor (43)
It's funny, people on here complain about recruitment but don't want to cut crap players.
Blame management but want to keep the moto well there's no one else in the whole country apparently after management made these decisions to sign the players.
Say a 20 year old should dropped but a 26 year old should be kept who has had long enough
I guess we should keep getting the spoon then.
Strange
Blame management but want to keep the moto well there's no one else in the whole country apparently after management made these decisions to sign the players.
Say a 20 year old should dropped but a 26 year old should be kept who has had long enough
I guess we should keep getting the spoon then.
Strange
Blackadder
Desmond Connor (43)
And I can't handle another season of listening to everything is awesome and watch the team continue to go down the toilet
You haven't come up with an alternative. There is no one in the SS currently who is up to it, the James Turner performance proved that.
Your example is poor as Newsome has been solid throughout SRTT, 2 tries and a number of good bust, whereas Mark N (Nawaqanitawase) has struggled.
In order for the Tahs to avoid the spoon, they need to build depth. They let that middle tier of players (Wells, Miller etc) go when the Foley and Phipps generation were running the show and has left us in the current predicament. My view is the like of Newsome and Foketi should be kept around to ease the burden on the next generation.
Your example is poor as Newsome has been solid throughout SRTT, 2 tries and a number of good bust, whereas Mark N (Nawaqanitawase) has struggled.
In order for the Tahs to avoid the spoon, they need to build depth. They let that middle tier of players (Wells, Miller etc) go when the Foley and Phipps generation were running the show and has left us in the current predicament. My view is the like of Newsome and Foketi should be kept around to ease the burden on the next generation.
Blackadder
Desmond Connor (43)
Recruitment. Recruitment.
Doesn't have to be from shute shield, whole country to look at.
Look around and find someone don't keep a player who is rubbish. Keeping a player saying well there is no one else apparently is the reason the Tahs go nowhere, accept average to rubbish keep producing same.